Prolepsia forecastYes / no

Will any US state enact a law imposing a statewide moratorium on new data centres between 1 January and 31 December 2027?

As of 17 November 2026, Prolepsia puts the chance of yes at 98%.

98%chance of yes

Yes 98%No 2%
Prolepsia forecast made

How Prolepsia reasons

The report Prolepsia wrote with this forecast.

How forecasts are made · Track record

TL;DR

The forecast is 97.6% Yes and 2.4% No for at least one qualifying state statute enacted during 2027. New Hampshire and Maine provide the strongest routes; New York’s existing executive moratorium does not itself count.

Key evidence

  • New Hampshire has a specific legislative vehicle. Governor Kelly Ayotte said she would put a statewide moratorium in her next state budget, linking her commitment to a legislative process rather than executive action alone (NHPR interview). The official registry also lists separate drafting requests for a temporary moratorium and a construction-and-expansion pause (General Court registry).
  • Maine is revisiting a measure that already cleared both chambers. LD 307 passed the legislature but was vetoed, and the override failed (official legislative history). Senator Nicole Grohoski has resubmitted moratorium language with a November 1, 2027 sunset and an emergency preamble (sponsor announcement). Governor-elect Hannah Pingree has reaffirmed support (Maine Morning Star).
  • There are additional routes, not just two. Maryland Governor Wes Moore said he would sign a statewide moratorium bill reaching him in 2027 (interview report). Virginia’s proposed SB 843 contains an explicit statewide approvals-and-permitting freeze (official text).

Uncertainties

The historical record is the strongest caution. NCSL’s September 2026 review identified proposals in 16 states but no enacted statutory moratorium in that snapshot (NCSL). Political support does not guarantee qualifying legislation.

Maine’s emergency procedure requires two-thirds support in each chamber, while New Hampshire’s final budget language remains unsettled. Across states, permanent regulation, executive pauses, or incentive changes could replace statutory moratoriums. These risks are shared, so the state opportunities are not independent.

Timing also matters: a law enacted in 2026 does not count simply because it takes effect in 2027. The forecast concerns enactment during 2027, not whether a moratorium is operating that year.

Read the full report

TL;DR

The forecast is 97.6% Yes and 2.4% No that at least one US state enacts a qualifying statewide data-centre moratorium during 2027. New Hampshire and Maine are the strongest routes because they combine explicit legislative plans with gubernatorial support. The decisive distinction is a statute enacted in the required year, not an executive pause or a promise to regulate.

Context

The question concerns a narrow legal event within a broad political backlash. A qualifying law must temporarily stop new development, construction, or essential approvals statewide, either for all data centres or for a defined category. Additional standards, taxes, incentive freezes, and local restrictions do not qualify. Neither does an executive order. Enactment must occur during 2027; the date the restriction takes effect is secondary.

As of the forecast date, November 17, 2026, several states have moved beyond general expressions of concern. The clearest preparations are New Hampshire’s budget commitment and legislative drafting requests, and Maine’s resubmitted moratorium language. New York supplies a prominent executive precedent, while Virginia supplies explicit proposed statutory language. These developments support a strong Yes forecast, but none should be mistaken for an already completed qualifying enactment.

Evidence

The historical starting point is cautionary. NCSL’s September 15, 2026 review identified moratorium proposals in 16 states, but no enacted statutory moratorium in that snapshot (NCSL review). An October 2026 Berkeley Lab review likewise distinguished proposed statewide moratoriums from enacted statutes and reported none enacted by statute (Berkeley Lab review). There is no established pattern of states routinely passing these laws.

That record is not a clean passage-rate sample. The proposals were at different stages, faced different political barriers, and did not represent independent, completed trials. Still, it establishes the central obstacle: concern about data centres often becomes something other than a statutory pause. The forecast rests on specific changes in legislative readiness, not on treating every proposal as another likely law.

New Hampshire offers the clearest connection between a governor’s commitment and a legislative vehicle. In her October 19 interview, Governor Kelly Ayotte said she would include a statewide moratorium in the next state budget (NHPR interview). That matters because it identifies a route through the legislature during the forecast year. It is stronger evidence than a generic pledge to oppose data centres.

The official General Court registry also lists Thomas Cormen’s LSR 2027-0002, titled “establishing a temporary moratorium on data centers,” and Daniel Innis’s LSR 2027-0301, concerning postponement of construction and expansion (official drafting-request registry). These are drafting requests, not enacted bills. They nevertheless show that the issue has identifiable legislative sponsors and is entering the next session’s agenda.

Sponsor descriptions give a sense of the intended scope. Cormen described a pause covering facilities with at least 20 megawatts of peak demand through the end of 2028; Innis described a shorter pause ending in 2027. The same reporting records that Innis lost reelection, which weakens his proposal as a continuing sponsorship route (New Hampshire Bulletin). The stronger inference comes from Ayotte’s budget commitment alongside Cormen’s request, not from counting every draft as a separate assured opportunity. Final statutory language remains essential.

Maine has a different advantage: its legislature has already demonstrated support for a moratorium. LD 307 passed on April 14, 2026, by 79–62 in the House and 21–13 in the Senate. Governor Janet Mills vetoed it on April 24, and a 72–65 House override vote on April 29 failed to overcome the veto (official legislative history). These votes show real legislative backing, but they did not produce a law.

The reason for that veto matters. Mills supported a temporary pause in principle but objected to the absence of an exemption for the proposed Jay mill redevelopment (governor’s explanation). The obstacle was therefore not a categorical rejection of moratoriums. A revised exemption could address that objection, and the question explicitly allows exemptions within an otherwise qualifying statewide restriction.

The next attempt is already concrete. A November 16 sponsor announcement says Senator Nicole Grohoski has resubmitted the moratorium language, retaining a November 1, 2027 sunset and adding an emergency preamble. It also identifies January 29, 2027 as the advisory council’s reporting deadline (sponsor announcement). Reporting on November 17 records Governor-elect Hannah Pingree reaffirming her support, while noting that the Jay project has revived (Maine Morning Star). The gubernatorial position is more favorable, but the project-specific dispute remains live.

Maine’s emergency procedure is a serious constraint. Its constitution requires two-thirds of all elected members in each chamber for emergency legislation, rather than an ordinary majority (Maine Constitution). Removing emergency treatment or negotiating exemptions offers a possible route around that barrier, but no such agreement is established. The short sunset also limits the practical value of a delayed law. These are reasons to distinguish strong prospects from guaranteed passage.

Other states broaden the opportunity. Maryland Governor Wes Moore explicitly said he would sign a statewide moratorium bill reaching him in 2027 (interview report). That reduces one potential barrier without proving legislative support. Oregon lawmakers have proposed a three-year statewide moratorium, but the governor’s separate administrative pause concerns state-property transactions and does not itself qualify (legislative proposal; governor’s directive). Michigan’s Jocelyn Benson has also called for a moratorium pending safeguards, which establishes intent rather than completed legislative agreement (campaign statement).

Virginia provides particularly clear proposed legal language. SB 843 was prefiled on October 9, 2026 and would suspend local final approvals and state development-related permissions beginning July 1, 2027, with expiration on July 1, 2030 (official bill text). This is a qualifying design if enacted during the required year. The text proves scope, not passage prospects.

New York requires the opposite distinction. Its official A11560 history records passage through both chambers on June 4, 2026, rather than enactment (official bill history). Governor Kathy Hochul’s July 14 announcement describes an executive-order moratorium (governor’s announcement). Neither fact independently satisfies this question. A qualifying statute enacted during 2027 would count; a 2026 signature or continued executive restriction would not.

What's non-obvious

The strongest evidence is not the most prominent headline. New York already has a statewide executive pause, but New Hampshire’s budget commitment is more directly aligned with the event being forecast. Maine’s failed bill is also more informative than a fresh statement of support: it demonstrates legislative willingness and identifies the earlier veto dispute. The key advantage is specificity about the legal route, not the volume of opposition.

A second point cuts against the high forecast. A strong regulatory response can still resolve No. Every leading state could address electricity demand, water use, and siting concerns through permanent safeguards or executive action without enacting a qualifying temporary statutory suspension. State opportunities therefore share a failure mode. The confidence comes from the breadth and concreteness of the legislative routes, not from assuming those routes are independent.

Uncertainties

The largest unresolved issue is final operative language. New Hampshire’s budget must retain an actual suspension, rather than studies or tougher conditions. Maine must settle its emergency procedure, exemptions, and timetable. Published bill text, committee action, leadership commitments, and recorded votes would close much of this gap. Drafting requests and supportive interviews cannot substitute for those records.

Timing creates another failure mode. An otherwise qualifying law enacted before 2027 does not count, even if its restriction operates during that year. Conversely, a statute enacted during 2027 counts even if its pause begins later. New York’s pending legislative history and Maine’s short proposed sunset make this distinction especially relevant.

Finally, the historical evidence remains thin. There is no reliable annual base rate here, and there is no verified moratorium-specific majority for every promising state. Shared lobbying pressure and a common preference for regulatory compromise could weaken several routes together. Those uncertainties account for the No outcome without changing the central conclusion: the identified legislative preparations strongly favor at least one qualifying enactment.

Forecast history

How Prolepsia’s forecast has movedOne forecast so far: 98% on 17 Nov 2026.
DateForecast
98% chance of yes

Sources Prolepsia read

  1. Which States Are Banning Data Centers?www.ncsl.org
  2. Data Center Siting: Criteria, Policies, and Recent Trendseta-publications.lbl.gov
  3. Governor Ayotte discusses energy, housing, and data centers | New Hampshire Public Radiowww.nhpr.org
  4. New Hampshire Legislative Service Requests (LSR's)gc.nh.gov
  5. Lawmakers say push from public, governor behind new batch of proposed data center guardrails • New Hampshire Bulletinnewhampshirebulletin.com
  6. Actionswww.mainelegislature.org
  7. Governor Mills Announces Decision on LD 307 | Office of Governor Janet T. Millswww3.maine.gov
  8. Sen. Grohoski, Sen.-elect Warren announce plan for regulating data centers in the next legislative session - Maine Senate Democratswww.mainesenate.org
  9. Lawmakers already preparing data center moratorium as they look ahead to January • Maine Morning Starmainemorningstar.com
  10. Maine Constitutionlegislature.maine.gov

The question

This question asks whether at least one of the 50 US states will enact a state law imposing a statewide moratorium on the development of new data centres between 1 January 2027 and 31 December 2027, inclusive. A qualifying moratorium must temporarily prohibit or suspend the approval, permitting, construction, or development of new data centres across the entire state, or across the entire state for a clearly defined category of data centres, such as large-scale or hyperscale facilities. The law must establish a binding restriction on new developments rather than merely introducing additional regulatory requirements, financial disincentives, or permitting conditions. As of 17 November 2026, several states have considered legislation restricting new data centre development. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL), proposals have included moratoriums in Virginia, Oklahoma, South Carolina, and New York. New York became the first state to impose a statewide moratorium on new hyperscale data centres through an executive order issued by Governor Kathy Hochul on 14 July 2026, but this was an executive action rather than an enacted statute. New York's legislature also passed moratorium legislation in June 2026. Virginia has proposed legislation that would restrict new data centre approvals beginning in July 2027. These developments illustrate growing legislative interest in addressing concerns about electricity demand, grid capacity, water consumption, and the environmental effects of data centre expansion. The forecast concerns laws enacted during calendar year 2027, regardless of whether the legislation was introduced in 2026 or 2027, and regardless of whether the moratorium takes effect immediately or at a later date. Background sources include the NCSL's 2026 review of state data centre moratorium proposals (https://www.ncsl.org/fiscal/which-states-are-banning-data-centers/utm), the New York governor's announcement of the July 2026 moratorium (https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/first-statewide-moratorium-new-hyperscale-data-centers-launched-governor-kathy-hochul), and Virginia's proposed 2027 legislation (https://lis.blob.core.windows.net/files/1231911.PDF).

How it resolves

The question resolves YES if, between 1 January 2027 and 31 December 2027, inclusive, at least one of the 50 US states enacts a binding state statute establishing a statewide moratorium on new data centre development. Enactment means that a bill has completed the legislative process and become law under the relevant state's constitutional procedures, including through a governor's signature, passage over a gubernatorial veto, or automatic enactment without a governor's signature. A moratorium qualifies if it explicitly suspends or prohibits the issuance of approvals or permits necessary for new data centre development, or directly prohibits the commencement of construction or development of new data centres, for a defined period or until specified conditions are satisfied. A moratorium may apply to all new data centres or to a clearly defined category, such as facilities above a specified electricity consumption, capacity, or size threshold, provided the restriction applies throughout the state to all facilities within that category. A prohibition on one essential category of state permits qualifies if it effectively prevents covered new data centres from obtaining the authorisation necessary to proceed. A law qualifies even if it contains exemptions for previously approved projects, existing facilities, emergency infrastructure, or other explicitly exempted categories. The question resolves NO if no qualifying state statute is enacted by 31 December 2027. The following do not qualify: executive orders issued without enactment of a state statute; local or county ordinances; voluntary industry commitments; nonbinding resolutions; legislation that is introduced or approved by only one legislative chamber but never becomes law; laws that only impose taxes, remove financial incentives, require additional studies, or establish new compliance standards without suspending new development approvals; and federal legislation. Resolution will be determined by examining official state legislative records, enrolled bills, governors' signing records, and published state session laws. The NCSL's legislative tracking resources may be used to identify relevant legislation, but official state records will take precedence when sources disagree. Enactment dates will be determined according to the official records and local calendar dates of the respective states. The question may be resolved YES as soon as a qualifying law is enacted. Otherwise, it will resolve NO after 31 December 2027 once the legislative records necessary to establish the outcome are available. If the official record of a potentially decisive enactment cannot be established reliably, resolution will be deferred while authoritative information is sought; the question will be annulled only if the outcome ultimately cannot be determined.

Fine print

For this question, 'statewide' means that the restriction applies throughout the geographical jurisdiction of a state to the relevant category of data centres, rather than being limited to particular municipalities, counties, or designated development zones. A statute does not need to prohibit every type of data centre to qualify. For example, a statewide moratorium on new facilities exceeding 20 megawatts would qualify, even if smaller facilities remained permissible. A statute imposing a temporary statewide suspension of new environmental permits specifically required for covered data centres would also qualify, provided those permits are necessary for their development. Conversely, a law that temporarily freezes only tax incentives, electricity rate agreements, or optional approvals would not qualify unless it legally prevents covered new facilities from proceeding. The moratorium may be temporary, indefinite pending regulatory review, or subject to termination upon the satisfaction of specified conditions. Permanent bans that are not structured as moratoriums are excluded. Legislation enacted before 1 January 2027 does not qualify merely because its moratorium takes effect during 2027. Legislation enacted during 2027 qualifies even if its moratorium begins in 2028 or later. A qualifying law counts if it is validly enacted during 2027, even if subsequently repealed, amended, suspended, or invalidated. Washington, DC, Puerto Rico, and other US territories are excluded because the question specifically refers to US states. Existing executive-order moratoriums, including New York's July 2026 action, do not independently qualify; however, a statute enacted during 2027 that codifies or independently establishes such a moratorium would qualify.