Prolepsia forecastYes / no
Will the BVP Nasdaq Emerging Cloud Index close 2027 higher than it closed 2026?
As of 15 November 2026, Prolepsia puts the chance of yes at 62%.
62%chance of yes
How Prolepsia reasons
The report Prolepsia wrote with this forecast.
How forecasts are made · Track record
TL;DR
The forecast is 62.1% Yes and 37.9% No for EMCLOUD to finish 2027 above its final 2026 closing level. This is a modest positive-return call, supported by underlying business growth but constrained by volatile valuations and mixed evidence on AI’s effects on software vendors.
Key evidence
- The historical record favors growth, but not a strong directional call. EMCLOUD rose in four of seven complete calendar years from 2019–2025. Its mean annual log return was 9.641%, against a sample standard deviation of 45.600%—a short history with very large swings (FRED). The broader Nasdaq Composite posted positive returns in 40 of 54 years from 1972–2025, but its broader, capitalization-weighted structure makes that an imperfect comparison (FRED).
- Demand remains substantial, but growth is uneven. Bessemer’s constituent snapshot showed median displayed revenue growth of 18.4%, although its observation dates were unclear (BVP). ServiceNow reported subscription-revenue growth of 21%, while monday.com’s forward indicators showed slowing contracted growth (ServiceNow; monday.com).
- Valuation remains a headwind. The ten-year inflation-indexed Treasury yield rose from 2.60% at October’s end to 2.86% on November 12, 2026 (FRED). EMCLOUD’s equal weighting also limits how much a few prominent AI winners can determine index performance (Nasdaq methodology).
Uncertainties
The central uncertainty is whether revenue growth translates into per-share value after competition, costs, dilution, and changes in valuation multiples. AI can create new sales while also weakening existing seat-based pricing; current disclosures do not establish the net index-wide effect.
The starting valuation is also unknown. EMCLOUD’s November 13, 2026 close of 2,010.93 points is not the comparison baseline (Nasdaq). The outcome uses the official price-index closes at the ends of 2026 and 2027, not an ETF, total-return index, or return from the forecast date.
Read the full report
TL;DR
The forecast is 62.1% Yes and 37.9% No for EMCLOUD to close 2027 above its final 2026 closing level. Continued cloud-software demand and positive long-run equity growth support Yes, while volatile valuations and competitive disruption keep the advantage modest. The decisive comparison starts at the end of 2026, so gains before then do not count toward a positive outcome.
Context
The question concerns the official EMCLOUD price-return index, not an ETF or the EMCLOUDT total-return index. A strictly higher final official close in 2027 resolves Yes; an equal or lower close resolves No. Nasdaq distinguishes the price and total-return versions in its index-versions document. If a specified year-end date has no official observation, the immediately preceding published close applies.
As of the November 15, 2026 forecast date, neither comparison endpoint is known. The latest available close was 2,010.93 points on November 13, 2026, and Nasdaq reported 64 constituents (Nasdaq overview). That gives context, not the hurdle for Yes. A rally or decline during the remaining weeks of 2026 changes the starting point for the measured year.
Evidence
The historical backbone supports a positive direction, but only a modest advantage. EMCLOUD’s complete calendar-year record contains four positive years and three negative years from 2019–2025. The full year-end history available through 2025 is below; 2018 supplies the starting observation rather than a complete calendar-year return (FRED historical series).
| Year | Year-end closing level, points |
|---|---|
| 2018 | 860.18 |
| 2019 | 1,205.40 |
| 2020 | 2,530.88 |
| 2021 | 2,461.45 |
| 2022 | 1,193.18 |
| 2023 | 1,671.67 |
| 2024 | 1,801.69 |
| 2025 | 1,689.21 |
These observations show why a bullish business story is not enough. The index more than doubled between the 2019 and 2020 endpoints, then lost more than half between the 2021 and 2022 endpoints. Across the seven complete years, mean annual log return was 9.641%, while sample annual log-return standard deviation was 45.600% (FRED data). The average direction was positive. The variation around it was much larger.
A longer reference class points the same way, but cannot be imported without adjustment. The Nasdaq Composite recorded 40 positive years among 54 complete annual returns from 1972–2025. Its mean annual log return was 9.845% (FRED Nasdaq Composite series). That supports positive long-run equity growth. It does not establish the same positive-year frequency for a narrower cloud-software index with different weights and business risks.
Index construction matters here. EMCLOUD is equal-weighted, with February and August reconstitutions and rebalances (Nasdaq methodology). A few large AI beneficiaries therefore cannot stand in for the whole index. The relevant question is whether progress spreads across cloud vendors, not whether the most visible technology companies keep growing.
The business backdrop provides support. Bessemer’s displayed constituent data showed median revenue growth of 18.4% and a median forward enterprise-value-to-revenue multiple of 4.6 times. The page did not establish clear, common observation dates for those figures (BVP constituent snapshot). I read this as evidence of an expanding business base, not a precisely dated measure of cheapness or a forecast of shareholder returns.
Evidence outside listed constituents also argues against immediate, universal demand destruction. Stripe’s September 10, 2026 analysis covered an average of 72,000 non-AI SaaS businesses weekly during 2026. Its same-business nominal payment measure showed year-over-year growth above 30%, alongside recovery in its median-business measure (Stripe analysis). This measures payments, not profit, and the businesses are not an EMCLOUD constituent sample. It weakens the case for an industry-wide collapse without proving that public shares offer attractive returns.
Company disclosures show both durable demand and slowing edges. ServiceNow reported quarterly subscription revenue of $3.988 billion, up 21%, and current remaining performance obligations—contracted revenue expected over the coming year—of $13.65 billion, up 20.5%. Its year-end AI contract-value target increased from $1.0 billion to $1.7 billion, but that was a target rather than realized revenue. December-quarter contracted-growth guidance softened to 18.5% (ServiceNow results). Acquisitions also mean reported growth is not a clean measure of organic demand (ServiceNow filing).
At monday.com, net dollar retention declined from 110% in March to 109% in June and 108% in September 2026. Among customers above $100,000 in annual recurring revenue, the corresponding figures were 115%, 115%, and 113% (second-quarter release; third-quarter release). These are trailing measures, not pure latest-quarter readings. Even so, the direction signals slower expansion within existing accounts. September AI annual recurring revenue of $36 million supplies counter-evidence, but does not erase the slowdown (third-quarter release).
Salesforce offers another example of strong AI demand with difficult comparisons. It reported Agentforce annual recurring revenue above $1.5 billion, up over 240%, but the definition newly included Slackbot and Headless 360. Subscription and support revenue also included $440 million from Informatica (Salesforce results). The disclosure demonstrates commercial traction. It does not establish like-for-like AI growth or revenue net of displaced conventional software seats.
Capital allocation adds another gap between sales growth and shareholder outcomes. Salesforce reported $27.332 billion in repurchases during the six months through July, against $1.763 billion of stock-based compensation. A $25 billion accelerated repurchase was financed with $25 billion principal of new notes (Salesforce filing). Repurchases can reduce share count, but debt financing changes the balance sheet. Neither buyback spending nor compensation expense alone measures net dilution.
Rates remain a valuation constraint. The ten-year inflation-indexed Treasury yield increased from 2.60% at October’s end to 2.86% on November 12, 2026 (FRED real-yield series). The Federal Reserve’s September projections put median 2027 real GDP growth at 2.4% and the year-end federal funds rate at 4.1%, unchanged from its projected 2026 endpoint (Federal Reserve projections). Those conditional projections describe expansion without a rate-cut windfall. They support business demand more than valuation expansion.
What's non-obvious
The distinction is between a growing industry and a rising price index. Revenue can grow while shareholders lose money if valuation multiples fall, costs rise, or share issuance absorbs part of the gain. The evidence supports continued cloud demand more clearly than it supports any particular valuation. That is why the forecast favors Yes without treating it as a strong bullish call.
The AI story is also less binary than the usual replacement-versus-windfall framing. The same vendor can sell new AI products while facing pressure on seats, pricing, and retention. Strong AI bookings do not establish the net benefit to shareholders, especially when product definitions or acquisition contributions change. Combined with equal weighting, this makes broad, comparable evidence across constituents more valuable than a few spectacular growth announcements.
Uncertainties
The largest uncertainty is the price investors will pay for future earnings at the start and end of the measured year. The 2026 closing baseline remains unknown. A strong finish to 2026 does not count toward Yes and can leave more demanding starting valuations; a weak finish can do the reverse. Neither effect is automatic, because the news moving prices also changes business expectations.
The historical sample is short and dominated by unusually large pandemic-era moves and their reversal. It establishes substantial risk, not a stable return pattern. Ordinary annual variability also does not capture every feature of a sudden market selloff or a lasting change in software economics.
The fundamental evidence has gaps. The selected company disclosures are not a representative index-wide sample. There is no comparable aggregate here for organic bookings, retention, dilution, or AI revenue net of displaced products. Bessemer’s unclear snapshot dates limit the valuation evidence. Consistently dated constituent data, comparable organic-growth disclosures, and net share-count changes would make the business-to-shareholder bridge clearer.
These uncertainties leave meaningful room for a negative year. They do not remove the positive case: an expanding business base and positive long-run equity growth still favor a higher closing level. The forecast remains 62.1% Yes and 37.9% No, conditional on the question remaining valid; its decimal precision does not imply equivalent predictive accuracy.
Forecast history
| Date | Forecast |
|---|---|
| 62% chance of yes |
Sources Prolepsia read
- Nasdaq Biotechnology Index (NBI) – Index Methodologyindexes.nasdaq.com
- Bessemer Venture Partners Nasdaq Emerging Cloud Index (NASDAQEMCLOUD) | FRED | St. Louis Fedfred.stlouisfed.org
- BVP - Companiescloudindex.bvp.com
- The SaaSpocalypse was more like a RenaiSaaSwww.stripeeconomics.com
- ServiceNow Reports Third Quarter 2026 Financial Results - ServiceNow Newsroomnewsroom.servicenow.com
- now-20260930www.sec.gov
- monday.com - monday.com Announces Second Quarter 2026 Resultsir.monday.com
- Salesforce.com, Inc. - Salesforce Delivers Record Second Quarter Fiscal 2027 Resultsinvestor.salesforce.com
- The Fed - September 16, 2026: FOMC Projections materials, accessible versionwww.federalreserve.gov
The question
This question asks whether the BVP Nasdaq Emerging Cloud Index (Nasdaq ticker: EMCLOUD) will finish calendar year 2027 at a higher closing level than it finishes calendar year 2026. The index, developed by Bessemer Venture Partners (BVP) and Nasdaq, tracks publicly traded companies primarily engaged in providing cloud-based software and services. It launched on October 2, 2018, with a base value of 1,000 points. The index follows a rules-based methodology and is periodically reconstituted and rebalanced to reflect eligible cloud software companies. As of November 2026, the index remains active, with its level around 2,000 points, although its performance has fluctuated substantially during 2026. The question is being formulated on November 15, 2026, before either year-end closing value is known. It compares the official closing value of the EMCLOUD price-return index on December 31, 2027, with its official closing value on December 31, 2026. The relevant measure is the index level in points, rather than the performance of an exchange-traded fund tracking the index or a total-return version that reinvests dividends. The forecast therefore concerns whether the index experiences a strictly positive price-level change between the final trading sessions of 2026 and 2027. Background and index information are available from Nasdaq (https://indexes.nasdaq.com/Index/Overview/EMCLOUD), Bessemer Venture Partners (https://cloudindex.bvp.com/), and the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis's FRED database (https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NASDAQEMCLOUD).
How it resolves
The question resolves YES if the official closing level of the BVP Nasdaq Emerging Cloud Index (EMCLOUD) on the final trading day of 2027 is strictly greater than its official closing level on the final trading day of 2026. It resolves NO if the 2027 closing level is equal to or lower than the 2026 closing level. The primary resolution source will be Nasdaq's official historical index data for EMCLOUD, available through its index overview and historical data pages (https://indexes.nasdaq.com/Index/Overview/EMCLOUD). The comparison dates are December 31, 2026, and December 31, 2027, provided the index publishes an official closing value on those dates. If either date is not an index calculation or trading day, the closing level from the immediately preceding day with an official published closing value will be used. The comparison will use the official closing index levels, not intraday highs, intraday lows, indicative values, or closing values of related financial products. If Nasdaq's historical records are unavailable, the FRED series NASDAQEMCLOUD, maintained by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NASDAQEMCLOUD), will serve as the secondary source. If neither source provides the necessary observations, other reputable historical market data providers may be consulted, provided their figures can be identified as the official EMCLOUD price-index closing levels. If the index is renamed or its ticker changes but Nasdaq maintains an identifiable continuous successor series, that successor series will be used. If the index is permanently discontinued before the final trading day of 2027 and no officially designated continuous successor exists, the question will be annulled rather than treating discontinuation as a negative return. The question will also be annulled if the necessary year-end values cannot be reliably established from the specified sources or credible alternatives. Resolution should occur once the official closing level for the final trading day of 2027 has been published and can be compared with the corresponding 2026 value.
Fine print
The question concerns the BVP Nasdaq Emerging Cloud Index under the ticker EMCLOUD, not the Nasdaq Composite Index, Nasdaq-100 Index, or the BVP Nasdaq Emerging Cloud Total Return Index (EMCLOUDT). Dividends and other cash distributions are not separately reinvested when calculating the outcome. The index's normal constituent changes, scheduled reconstitutions, rebalancing events, and methodology adjustments do not invalidate the question; the officially published index levels will be used. An increase of any positive magnitude qualifies as YES, while an unchanged closing level qualifies as NO. The comparison will use the greatest precision available in the official published closing values to avoid ambiguity from rounding. Both observations must belong to the same continuous index series, with any historical corrections or restatements officially published by Nasdaq before resolution incorporated into the comparison. Subsequent revisions after the question has been resolved will not ordinarily reopen the outcome. All dates refer to the calendar dates assigned to the index's official closing observations in the U.S. market, using Eastern Time. The question measures the change between the two specified year-end closing levels, not whether the index trades above its 2026 closing level at any point during 2027.
More public forecasts
Will the Nasdaq-100 index close 2027 higher than it closed 2026?
78%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will the Nasdaq Composite close 2027 higher than it closed 2026?
69%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will the MSCI Emerging Markets Index beat the MSCI World Index in 2027?
57%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will the Nasdaq-100 index close at least 20% below its previous all-time closing high on any trading day between 1 January and 31 December 2027?
64%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will a data-centre or AI cloud company with at least US$5 billion of debt file for bankruptcy or miss a scheduled bond or loan payment between 1 January and 31 December 2027?
31%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will worldwide public cloud spending in 2027 exceed $1 trillion, as reported by Gartner?
94%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast