Prolepsia forecastYes / no

Will the University of Michigan consumer sentiment index be above 65 in December 2027?

As of 18 November 2026, Prolepsia puts the chance of yes at 25%.

25%chance of yes

Yes 25%No 75%
Prolepsia forecast made

How Prolepsia reasons

The report Prolepsia wrote with this forecast.

How forecasts are made · Track record

TL;DR

Probability of Yes: 25.3%. Probability of No: 74.7%. A rebound is plausible, but the final December 2027 index needs to reach at least 65.1, a gain of 14.1 points from the preliminary November 2026 reading.

Key evidence

  • The starting point is low, and the weakness has lasted. Michigan reported 48.1 in September and 48.0 in October, both final, followed by a preliminary 51.0 in November. The last final reading above 65 was January 2025. Although 42 of 48 Decembers from 1978 through 2025 cleared 65, that record mostly reflects periods when sentiment started much higher. The rebound from 50.0 in June 2022 to 71.5 in July 2023 shows what is possible, but the similarly low April and May 2025 readings did not lead to crossings 13 months later. (Michigan historical readings; FRED history)
  • Cheaper gasoline helps, but it is not enough on its own. Regular gasoline fell from $4.478 per gallon on September 21 to $3.805 on November 16. The EIA projects $3.33 per gallon in the fourth quarter of 2027, down from $4.06 in the same quarter of 2026. But sentiment was only 56.6 in February 2026, before the latest fuel-price shock. (EIA pump prices; Michigan historical readings)
  • Other costs can absorb some of the savings. Marsh projects employer-sponsored health benefit costs will rise 8.2% in 2027 after rising 7.3% in 2026. Workers in large employers’ PPO plans paid an average of $528 more toward family coverage in 2026. The 8.2% projection is for total plan costs, not what workers will pay. (Marsh survey)

Uncertainties

The strongest path to Yes is cheaper energy translating into sustained gains in real income and perceived financial well-being without a rise in layoffs. An energy-price reversal or weaker employment would work against a rebound, and the amount of health cost growth passed on to workers remains unknown. Only the original final December 2027 Michigan headline reading counts. A preliminary or earlier reading above 65 does not qualify, and exactly 65.0 is No.

Read the full report

TL;DR

Probability of Yes: 25.3%. Probability of No: 74.7%. The key hurdle is a 14.1-point rise from November’s preliminary reading to the lowest qualifying final reading in December 2027 (Michigan Surveys of Consumers).

Context

As of November 18, 2026, the University of Michigan’s headline Index of Consumer Sentiment stood at 51.0 in the preliminary November release, up from final readings of 48.1 in September and 48.0 in October. That is an improvement, but it puts the index back at its November 2025 level rather than marking a break from the recent stretch of weakness. November’s final reading was not yet available. (Michigan Surveys of Consumers; Michigan historical readings)

The event is a strictly above-65.0 reading in the original final December 2027 release, which Michigan schedules for December 17. At the published precision, 65.1 qualifies and 65.0 does not. No earlier month, preliminary release, component index, or later revision determines the outcome. (Michigan Surveys of Consumers; FRED series description)

Evidence

The long history makes 65 look easy to clear. The headline index did so in 42 of 48 Decembers from 1978 through 2025. But most of those years began from much higher sentiment levels. The recent record is different: only two of the four Decembers from 2022 through 2025 cleared 65, and none of the 21 final monthly readings from February 2025 through October 2026 did. The question is not whether 65 was normal in the past. It is whether households can climb back there from a long stretch of low readings. (FRED monthly history; Michigan historical readings)

The low-start comparisons show both paths. Of six final readings at or below 55.0 with an observed final reading 13 months later, four cleared 65. But those four successes came from just two episodes, in 1980 and 2022. The two starts in the current episode both missed. The table puts the rebound and the misses alongside the December record and the latest readings. (FRED monthly history; Michigan historical readings; Michigan Surveys of Consumers)

Month Headline index Why it matters
June 2022 50.0 Start of a sharp rebound
December 2022 59.8 Below the threshold
July 2023 71.5 The rebound cleared 65 after 13 months
December 2023 69.7 Above the threshold
December 2024 74.0 Above the threshold
January 2025 71.7 Last final reading above 65 as of the forecast date
April 2025 52.2 Low start; did not clear 65 after 13 months
May 2025 52.2 Low start; did not clear 65 after 13 months
November 2025 51.0 Same level as the November 2026 preliminary reading
December 2025 52.9 Below the threshold
February 2026 56.6 Weak before the latest fuel-price shock
May 2026 44.8 Endpoint for the April 2025 comparison
June 2026 49.5 Endpoint for the May 2025 comparison
September 2026 48.1 Final
October 2026 48.0 Final
November 2026 51.0 Preliminary

Fuel is the clearest source of upside. Regular gasoline fell from $4.478 per gallon on September 21 to $4.153 on November 2 and $3.805 on November 16. The last two weekly drops came after the preliminary November survey’s October 20–November 2 interview window. They offer a reason for later readings to improve, not an explanation for the rise already reported. Even after those declines, the November 16 price was $0.743 per gallon higher than in the comparable week a year earlier. (EIA weekly gasoline prices; Michigan Surveys of Consumers)

The EIA projects gasoline at $3.33 per gallon in the fourth quarter of 2027, versus $4.06 in the fourth quarter of 2026. The Philadelphia Fed’s survey of forecasters projects headline CPI inflation slowing from 3.8% in 2026 to 2.4% in 2027, measured fourth quarter over fourth quarter. It puts unemployment at 4.3% in the fourth quarter of 2027, against the observed 4.1% in October 2026. That is a path to relief without a large rise in unemployment. But the 2022–23 recovery came with a larger fuel-price decline and a much sharper drop in inflation, from 9.1% to 3.2%. It shows that a rebound of the required size can happen, not that the current outlook is enough to repeat it. (EIA petroleum data; Philadelphia Fed forecaster survey; BLS October employment report; BLS CPI data)

Outside fuel, the evidence of relief is thinner. Michigan’s preliminary one-year inflation expectation fell from 4.7% to 4.3%, yet 57% of respondents volunteered that high prices were eroding their living standards, up from 46% in February. October real weekly earnings were flat from the previous month for private payroll employees and fell 0.3% for production and nonsupervisory employees. The average 30-year mortgage rate was still 7.11% on November 12. Slower inflation helps, but it does not undo the rise in the price level or make borrowing cheap. (Michigan Surveys of Consumers; BLS real earnings; Freddie Mac mortgage-rate archive)

What's non-obvious

Relief at the pump is not the same as relief in the household budget. Sentiment was only 56.6 in February 2026, before the latest fuel shock, so reversing the shock does not erase the weakness that came before it. Marsh reported that employer-sponsored health benefit costs rose 7.3% in 2026 and projects an 8.2% increase in 2027. At large employers with PPO plans, workers’ annual contributions for family coverage had already risen by an average of $528 in 2026. The 2027 forecast covers total plan costs, not worker premiums. It points to a possible offset to gasoline savings, not a bill that can be assigned to households in advance. (Michigan historical readings; Marsh health benefit survey)

The recent lows also are not simply a survey artifact. Michigan moved to web-only reporting in July 2024, but its like-for-like web comparison still put May 2026 below the June 2022 trough. And November’s preliminary rise was concentrated among independents, whose index rose from 42.4 to 52.1, while the readings for Democrats and Republicans both slipped. That does not negate the headline improvement. It does mean one preliminary month is not evidence of a broad turn. (Michigan survey-method comparison; Michigan party-group tables)

Uncertainties

There are too few distinct episodes at today’s starting level to say how quickly a slump this persistent normally ends. Nor is there a timely national measure of lower-income households’ real take-home pay after debt service. Wage, income, and credit data show pieces of that picture, and the amount of health benefit cost growth that employers will pass on to workers is not yet known.

The strongest evidence for a higher chance of Yes would be several months of cheaper fuel alongside rising real pay and better readings on personal finances and the affordability of major purchases. An energy-price reversal or weaker employment would make the hurdle harder. Timing matters as much as the direction: even a genuine recovery that clears 65 earlier in 2027 does not count if the original final December reading is back at or below 65.0. (Michigan Surveys of Consumers)

Forecast history

How Prolepsia’s forecast has movedOne forecast so far: 25% on 18 Nov 2026.
DateForecast
25% chance of yes

Sources Prolepsia read

  1. Surveys of Consumerswww.sca.isr.umich.edu
  2. University of Michigan: Consumer Sentiment (UMCSENT) | FRED | St. Louis Fedfred.stlouisfed.org
  3. Weekly U.S. Regular All Formulations Retail Gasoline Prices (Dollars per Gallon)www.eia.gov
  4. Fourth Quarter 2026 Survey of Professional Forecasterswww.philadelphiafed.org
  5. Employment Situation News Release - 2026 M10 Resultswww.bls.gov
  6. Freddie Mac mortgage-rate archivewww.freddiemac.com
  7. Employers Take Steps to Rein in Health Benefit Cost Growth as Average Cost Reaches $18,777 Per Employee, Marsh Survey Findsfinance.yahoo.com
  8. Special Report: Sentiment, Web-Based Data Collection, and Partisanshipdata.sca.isr.umich.edu
  9. University of Michigan: Consumer Sentiment | ALFRED | St. Louis Fedalfred.stlouisfed.org

The question

This question asks whether the University of Michigan's Index of Consumer Sentiment (ICS), a monthly measure of U.S. consumer confidence, will exceed 65.0 in December 2027. The index is produced by the University of Michigan's Surveys of Consumers and measures Americans' perceptions of their personal finances, current economic conditions, and future economic prospects. As of November 17, 2026, consumer sentiment remains historically weak. The final October 2026 index reading was 48.0, compared with 48.1 in September, while the preliminary November 2026 reading increased to 51.0. These figures indicate that sentiment would need to improve substantially to exceed 65.0 by December 2027. The survey publishes preliminary results during the month and final results toward the end of the month. This question specifically concerns the final published December 2027 Index of Consumer Sentiment, rather than the preliminary reading, the Index of Consumer Expectations, or the Index of Current Economic Conditions. The relevant observation period is December 2027, and resolution is expected following publication of that month's final survey results. Background sources: University of Michigan Surveys of Consumers (https://www.sca.isr.umich.edu/) and University of Michigan Survey Description (https://data.sca.isr.umich.edu/survey-description.php).

How it resolves

The question resolves YES if the University of Michigan's final December 2027 Index of Consumer Sentiment (ICS) is strictly greater than 65.0, as reported in the university's official December 2027 final Surveys of Consumers release. The question resolves NO if the final December 2027 reading is 65.0 or lower. A reading of exactly 65.0 resolves NO. The primary resolution source will be the University of Michigan Surveys of Consumers official website (https://www.sca.isr.umich.edu/) or its official historical data portal (https://data.sca.isr.umich.edu/). The value published in the original final December 2027 release will be authoritative, regardless of subsequent historical revisions. If the university's original final release is temporarily unavailable, the December 2027 observation in the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis FRED series UMCSENT (https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UMCSENT) may be used as a secondary source, provided it can be established that the observation corresponds to the original final December 2027 reading. If the preliminary December 2027 reading exceeds 65.0 but the final reading does not, the question resolves NO. Conversely, if the preliminary reading is 65.0 or lower but the final reading exceeds 65.0, the question resolves YES. If the December 2027 final release is delayed, resolution will be postponed until the relevant figure becomes available. If no official final December 2027 index value is published by June 30, 2028, and the original final value cannot be reliably established from the secondary source, the question will be annulled.

Fine print

The threshold of 65 refers to index points, not a percentage or percentage change. The question concerns the overall Index of Consumer Sentiment for the United States, not its individual components or demographic subgroups. Only the December 2027 monthly observation counts; readings above 65 in earlier months of 2027 do not qualify. The index must be strictly above 65.0, meaning that a published value of 65.1 or higher qualifies when reported to one decimal place. The original published final value, using the precision reported by the University of Michigan, determines resolution. Subsequent revisions, methodological changes, or rebasing of historical data will not alter the outcome once established. If the university changes its methodology before December 2027 but continues publishing a directly identified successor to the overall Index of Consumer Sentiment on a comparable scale, that successor will be used. If the index is discontinued or fundamentally redefined such that the 65-point threshold is no longer meaningfully comparable, and no official comparable December 2027 value is available, the question will be annulled.