Prolepsia forecastYes / no

Will the US House of Representatives impeach at least one sitting cabinet secretary between 1 January and 31 December 2027?

As of 17 November 2026, Prolepsia puts the chance of yes at 72%.

72%chance of yes

Yes 72%No 28%
Prolepsia forecast made

How Prolepsia reasons

The report Prolepsia wrote with this forecast.

How forecasts are made · Track record

TL;DR

The forecast is 72.2% Yes and 27.8% No that the House formally impeaches at least one sitting Cabinet secretary during 2027. Hegseth is the leading target; the central obstacle is keeping a qualifying target in office long enough for leadership to bring articles to a successful vote.

Key evidence

  • The coalition is substantial, but has not yet voted to impeach. On November 10, 2026, the House voted 211–204 to refer the Hegseth resolution to committee. All 203 participating Democrats opposed referral. That demonstrates procedural alignment, not commitments to approve particular articles (House Clerk).
  • Leadership supports renewed action. Jeffries endorsed Hegseth’s impeachment on November 8. Garcia said on November 12 that he expected another effort and described advance planning with committee leaders. Neither statement established a floor date (ABC News; Bloomberg Government).
  • The incoming majority offers a cushion. AP’s November 13 snapshot reported 256 Democratic victories, with ten races uncalled. This was not a certified final total, but it indicates that a small bloc of dissenters need not defeat impeachment (AP).
  • White House protection supports Hegseth’s continued service. November 14 reporting described active efforts to protect him. That strengthens the route to a qualifying vote without guaranteeing retention (CNN via KESQ).
  • Kennedy is a secondary target. Democrats have discussed impeaching him, but also have incentives to cooperate with his supporters (AP).

Uncertainties

Departure before adoption is the largest risk. A resignation or dismissal could satisfy Democrats politically while failing this question’s sitting-officeholder requirement. A departure after adoption would not erase a qualifying impeachment.

Scheduling is the other major uncertainty. Leadership endorsement is stronger than backbench pressure, but there is no verified floor timetable or completed incoming-caucus whip count. Committee work could strengthen the case, replace impeachment with oversight, or push adoption beyond 2027. Other targets do not eliminate these risks because they share the same leadership priorities and legislative calendar. Senate conviction is not required.

Read the full report

TL;DR

The forecast is 72.2% Yes and 27.8% No that the House impeaches at least one sitting Cabinet secretary during 2027. Hegseth is the principal route, supported by Democratic leadership and a substantial incoming majority. Watch the vote timetable and his continued service: departure before adoption or delay beyond 2027 defeats that route.

Context

As of November 17, 2026, Democrats are preparing to take control of the House, and Hegseth already faces a concrete impeachment effort. The outgoing House referred the resolution to committee rather than adopting articles. The question is whether the incoming political opportunity becomes formal House action within the calendar year (House Clerk).

The resolution standard is narrow. At least one article must pass the full House between January 1 and December 31, 2027, while the target serves as head of one of the 15 traditional executive departments. Acting secretaries and the Attorney General qualify; other Cabinet-rank officials do not. Committee proceedings and failed votes are insufficient. Senate conviction is unnecessary under the House’s impeachment process (Congressional Research Service).

Evidence

Cabinet impeachment is historically rare. The historical list contains two cases: William Belknap and Alejandro Mayorkas. Belknap resigned before the House impeached him on March 2, 1876, so his sequence would fail this question’s sitting-officeholder requirement. Mayorkas supplies the relevant modern precedent (Senate impeachment history; Belknap history).

The Mayorkas episode also shows the gap between intent and execution. The first vote failed 214–216 on February 6, 2024. The House then adopted impeachment articles 214–213 on February 13. Senate dismissal on April 17 did not undo the House’s action (House impeachment history). For this question, passage is the decisive event, not the outcome of a Senate proceeding.

A closer historical comparison is the five modern Congresses beginning after the opposition captured the House at a midterm: 1995–96, 2007–08, 2011–12, 2019–20 and 2023–24. None produced a qualifying secretary impeachment in its first calendar year. Only the last produced one during the full two-year Congress. This is a small, politically varied reference class, but its lesson is clear: an opposition majority does not automatically turn oversight promises into impeachment within a year (House majority changes; House impeachment history).

The present case differs from that ordinary starting point. Hegseth is already a named target with demonstrated procedural support and an explicit leadership endorsement. On November 10, 2026, the House voted 211–204 to refer H.Res.1655 to Judiciary, with 18 members not voting. All 203 voting Democrats opposed referral, joined by Massie. The official record establishes a referral, not impeachment and not a substantive rejection of the articles (House Clerk).

That distinction matters in both directions. The vote shows a large bloc willing to keep the effort moving. It does not establish that every member would approve the same charges after hearings. The allegations remain allegations, and procedural opposition is not an article-specific commitment.

The incoming majority reduces the danger that a few defections decide the outcome. AP’s November 13 election snapshot reported 256 Democratic victories, with ten races uncalled. That was a projection snapshot rather than a certified membership count. Still, it indicates a substantial cushion compared with a bare majority (AP election reporting). The inference is that leadership’s decision to proceed matters more than finding a handful of Republican votes.

Leadership signals are stronger than routine demands for accountability. Jeffries called himself a “hard yes” on Hegseth’s impeachment on November 8. On November 12, incoming Oversight chair Robert Garcia said he expected another effort and described months of planning with Judiciary’s Jamie Raskin and leadership (ABC News; Bloomberg Government). Those statements support follow-through, but they do not establish a markup or floor date.

Committee preparation cuts both ways. Reporting on November 11 described efforts to refine charges and build a committee-led case. That makes the effort more substantive than a symbolic introduction. It also creates more time for a personnel change or a shift in priorities (WIRED).

Incoming members show the same tension. Statements from three Colorado Democrats included support for impeachment proceedings, emphasis on immediate economic priorities, and a preference for testimony and subpoenas. This is a selected three-person sample, not a caucus survey. It nevertheless illustrates why support for accountability does not settle its form or timing (Colorado Newsline).

Hegseth’s job security is the largest competing consideration. Trump promised to stand by him even if impeached, and the White House formally urged referral of the resolution. November 14 reporting also described active efforts by officials to protect him (ABC News; White House policy statement; CNN via KESQ). These are concrete retention signals, not a guarantee that he stays through a vote.

There are contrary signals. Reporting described Trump soliciting views on Hegseth’s performance, and Trump acknowledged that confirming a replacement would be easier before Democrats assumed Senate control (ABC News). A reported Senate-seat exit route was weakened by reporting that Blackburn was not considering him. That closes neither the resignation nor dismissal route (USA Today via AOL).

Kennedy provides the clearest secondary route. AP reported that Clyburn identified him as an impeachment priority and Raskin promised investigation. The same account described Democratic efforts to court Kennedy-aligned voters, creating an incentive for selective cooperation rather than immediate confrontation (AP). Existing resolutions against Kennedy and McMahon remained at referral rather than adoption. Their existence establishes additional targets, not floor-ready coalitions (Kennedy legislative history; McMahon legislative history).

What's non-obvious

More pressure does not necessarily mean a higher chance of a qualifying impeachment. Stronger evidence can persuade members to vote, but it can also persuade the president to dismiss the secretary first. Under these rules, the order of events is decisive. A politically successful campaign that forces departure before adoption fails to qualify; departure after adoption does not matter.

The other easy mistake is to treat the number of potential targets as a set of separate opportunities. They share leadership, committee capacity, floor time and electoral incentives. If Hegseth alone leaves, another target remains a route to Yes. If leadership decides that impeachment displaces its economic agenda, several routes weaken together. The forecast therefore rests mainly on a developed Hegseth effort, not simply on the existence of many controversial officials.

Uncertainties

The central missing facts are a firm timetable, a completed incoming-caucus whip count, and reliable evidence about Hegseth’s continued tenure. None is established. That is not proof that planning or personnel discussions are absent. It means public commitments cannot yet be treated as a scheduled outcome.

A committee schedule, agreed articles and a leadership-backed floor date would clarify the timing risk. A verified successor-selection process or departure agreement would clarify retention risk. For secondary targets, the useful evidence would be movement from statements and referrals toward a committee-backed case and explicit leadership support.

Historical rarity remains a real caution, especially for a first-year deadline. The case for Yes is that the current effort starts with more concrete support than a generic opposition takeover. The main reasons it can still fail are departure before adoption, investigation extending beyond 2027, or a leadership decision to pursue oversight without impeachment.

Forecast history

How Prolepsia’s forecast has movedOne forecast so far: 72% on 17 Nov 2026.
DateForecast
72% chance of yes

Sources Prolepsia read

  1. Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representativesclerk.house.gov
  2. Congressional Research Servicewww.congress.gov
  3. U.S. Senate: About Impeachment | Impeachment Caseswww.senate.gov
  4. List of Individuals Impeached by the House of Representatives | US House of Representatives: History, Art & Archiveshistory.house.gov
  5. The Latest: Supreme Court to consider Trump’s order suspending asylum access at southern border | AP Newsapnews.com
  6. 'I'm a hard yes': Hakeem Jeffries announces support for Hegseth impeachment - ABC Newsabcnews.com
  7. Hegseth Will Face Impeachment Again, Top Oversight Democrat Saysnews.bgov.com
  8. Pete Hegseth Is About to Get His Ass Kicked | WIREDwww.wired.com
  9. Colorado Democrats heading to Congress seek accountability for Trump administration, Hegseth | Colorado Newslinecoloradonewsline.com
  10. A Resolution Impeaching Peter Brian Hegseth, Secretary of Warwww.whitehouse.gov

The question

This question asks whether the United States House of Representatives will formally impeach at least one sitting U.S. Cabinet secretary during the calendar year 2027, from January 1, 2027, through December 31, 2027, inclusive. Under Article I of the U.S. Constitution, the House has the sole power of impeachment. Impeachment occurs when the full House approves at least one article of impeachment by a simple majority of members voting, assuming a quorum is present. Senate conviction or removal from office is not required. Cabinet secretaries are eligible for impeachment, as demonstrated by the House's impeachment of Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas on February 13, 2024. As of November 17, 2026, Donald Trump is serving his second presidential term, and Democrats are preparing to assume control of the House following the November 2026 midterm elections. Impeachment of administration officials has become an active political issue. In November 2026, Representative Thomas Massie introduced articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, but the House did not approve them. The upcoming change in House control may affect the likelihood of impeachment proceedings against executive branch officials in 2027. This question concerns the formal adoption of impeachment articles against any qualifying Cabinet secretary during 2027, regardless of political affiliation, the allegations involved, or the eventual outcome of any Senate proceedings. Sources: U.S. Senate, About Impeachment (https://www.senate.gov/about/powers-procedures/impeachment.htm); Congressional Research Service, The Impeachment Process in the House of Representatives (https://www.congress.gov/crs_external_products/R/PDF/R45769/R45769.12.pdf); Associated Press, November 2026 reporting on Cabinet impeachment proceedings (https://apnews.com/article/cfb2e0b84116b12bc955bf2eb550a35c).

How it resolves

The question resolves YES if, at any point from January 1, 2027, through December 31, 2027, inclusive, the full U.S. House of Representatives formally adopts at least one article of impeachment against an individual who is serving as the secretary and head of one of the 15 executive departments that constitute the traditional U.S. Cabinet at the time of the vote. The qualifying departments are State, Treasury, Defense, Justice, Interior, Agriculture, Commerce, Labor, Health and Human Services, Housing and Urban Development, Transportation, Energy, Education, Veterans Affairs, and Homeland Security. The Attorney General, as head of the Department of Justice, is included. The question resolves YES as soon as the House successfully adopts at least one article of impeachment against a qualifying officeholder, regardless of whether the Senate subsequently holds a trial, convicts, acquits, or dismisses the charges. The question resolves NO if December 31, 2027, passes without the full House adopting any article of impeachment against a qualifying Cabinet secretary who was serving in that position at the time of adoption. Introducing articles of impeachment, initiating an impeachment inquiry, holding committee hearings, approving articles in committee, or voting on articles that fail to pass the full House do not qualify. The primary resolution sources will be the official House Clerk's roll-call records, the Congressional Record, and the official legislative histories of impeachment resolutions published by Congress.gov. A successful impeachment established by these official records is sufficient for a YES resolution. If the House adopts articles through a voice vote or another procedure without a recorded roll-call vote, the Congressional Record and official House proceedings will be used to establish whether the articles were adopted. If official records are temporarily unavailable, resolution will be deferred until they can be consulted, with contemporaneous reporting by reputable national news organizations used as supplementary evidence. If the official records remain permanently unavailable or contradictory and the outcome cannot be reliably established, the question will be annulled.

Fine print

For purposes of this question, 'Cabinet secretary' refers exclusively to the heads of the 15 traditional executive departments, including the Attorney General. Cabinet-rank officials who do not head one of these departments, such as the White House Chief of Staff, Director of National Intelligence, Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency, or Director of the Office of Management and Budget, are excluded, even if the president grants them Cabinet-level status. Acting secretaries are included if they are officially performing the duties of a department secretary at the time the House adopts the articles of impeachment. An individual who resigns, is removed, or otherwise ceases to serve as secretary before the House adopts the articles does not qualify, even if the alleged misconduct occurred while that individual was in office. An impeachment of a former secretary therefore does not count. An individual who is serving as secretary when the House adopts the articles qualifies even if that individual subsequently resigns or is removed before Senate proceedings. Impeachment articles introduced before January 1, 2027, qualify if the full House adopts them during the specified 2027 window. Articles adopted before January 1, 2027, do not qualify, even if Senate proceedings occur in 2027. If the House approves multiple articles against the same secretary, this counts as one qualifying impeachment event; only one such event is needed for a YES resolution. Dates will be determined using the official legislative date recorded by the House, with Eastern Time used to resolve any ambiguity about whether an action occurred within the specified calendar-year window. The question is not conditional on a particular party controlling the House, a particular individual remaining in office, or any impeachment inquiry being opened.