Prolepsia forecastYes / no

Will the US House of Representatives impeach Donald Trump between 1 January and 31 December 2027?

As of 17 November 2026, Prolepsia puts the chance of yes at 38%.

38%chance of yes

Yes 38%No 62%
Prolepsia forecast made

How Prolepsia reasons

The report Prolepsia wrote with this forecast.

How forecasts are made · Track record

TL;DR

The forecast is 38.1% Yes and 61.9% No for a qualifying House impeachment of Donald Trump during 2027. Democratic control makes impeachment feasible, but leadership’s willingness to pursue and complete it—not simply possession of a majority—is the main obstacle.

Key evidence

  • Leadership is keeping the option open, not promising a vote. Jeffries’s November 4 agenda prioritizes healthcare, food assistance, tariffs and the Iran war. His November 10 interview explicitly backs proceeding against Hegseth while leaving other impeachments undecided. That distinction weighs against treating presidential impeachment as the incoming majority’s settled plan. (Agenda; interview)
  • Recorded support is substantial but falls short of a demonstrated adoption coalition. On September 15, 2026, the House voted 232–147 to table a Trump impeachment resolution, with 47 voting present. Opposing tabling is not the same as supporting final impeachment. (House Clerk)
  • Post-election caution is affirmative evidence. Raskin has argued for prioritizing healthcare, while November 16 reporting describes Democratic disagreement and concern that impeachment could revive Trump’s political support. (GW Today; The Independent)
  • Investigations provide a credible path to a changed decision. Lawmakers are examining Trump-linked fundraising, and White House restrictions on congressional testimony create scope for either escalation or delay. Allegations remain allegations, not established misconduct. (Fundraising inquiry; Axios)

Uncertainties

The largest unknown is whether new evidence or a crisis changes leadership’s calculation early enough for adoption by December 31, 2027. Investigations could instead remain diffuse, focus on Cabinet officials, or become tied up in disputes over records and testimony. No verified presidential-impeachment timetable or incoming-caucus whip count establishes that a vote is ready.

Only full-House adoption of an article counts. Senate conviction is unnecessary, although members’ views about a subsequent trial can still affect whether they choose to impeach. (USAGov)

Read the full report

TL;DR

The forecast is 38.1% Yes and 61.9% No for the House formally impeaching Donald Trump during calendar 2027. Democratic control supplies the institutional opportunity, but leadership has not committed to a presidential impeachment campaign. Watch for leadership-backed articles and a floor timetable, not investigation announcements or procedural votes.

Context

As of November 17, 2026, Democrats have won control of both congressional chambers, creating an opening for investigations and impeachment efforts when the new Congress convenes. Election reporting establishes the change in control, but the reported seat totals remain provisional rather than a final certified membership count. The central political question is whether Democrats turn their new authority into a completed presidential impeachment during the first year. (Election reporting)

The resolution threshold is narrower than the political debate. At least one article against Trump must be formally adopted by the full House between January 1 and December 31, 2027, inclusive, in Washington time. An inquiry, committee action or procedural vote does not qualify. Senate conviction is a separate process and is unnecessary for this question. (USAGov)

Evidence

History provides a useful restraint against assuming that opposition control leads naturally to impeachment. The relevant comparison is the first calendar year after a postwar midterm transferred House control to the sitting president’s opposition. The full set contains seven cases, with only one qualifying presidential impeachment. This is a constructed reference class using official party-control and impeachment histories, not an official published forecasting statistic. (House party divisions; impeachment history)

First year after opposition takeover Presidential impeachment that year
1947 No
1955 No
1995 No
2007 No
2011 No
2019 Yes
2023 No

That record argues against inevitability, not against taking the present risk seriously. Trump differs from most presidents in the comparison: the House impeached him on December 18, 2019, and January 13, 2021. Those episodes establish that a House majority has twice been willing to take this step against him. They are also selected, related events, not independent evidence that each year under a Democratic House produces impeachment. (Official impeachment list)

The incoming majority supplies real capacity. Cook’s November 16 snapshot reported 256 Democratic and 169 Republican victories, with ten races outside those totals. It also identified at least 55 Democratic winners in districts Trump carried in 2024. These are provisional called results. They suggest room for defections, alongside a sizable group with reasons for political caution; they do not establish how those members would vote on an article. (Cook Political Report)

Recorded behavior shows that the constituency for keeping impeachment alive has expanded. The available history of Democratic votes against tabling Trump impeachment resolutions is:

Date Resolution Democrats opposing tabling Democratic members listed
June 24, 2025 H.Res.537 79 212
December 11, 2025 H.Res.939 140 213
September 15, 2026 H.Res.1486 147 214

The June observation comes from the official roll call; the September observation comes from the official September record. The pattern shows a large increase followed by a smaller one. Different allegations and leadership instructions limit comparability. Most importantly, these votes concern whether consideration should continue, not whether an article should be adopted.

The September result makes that distinction concrete. The House voted 232–147 to table the resolution, with 47 present. Democrats divided 18 for tabling, 147 against, 46 present and three not voting. Jeffries voted present; Raskin opposed tabling. This is evidence of substantial interest and unresolved caution, not proof of an impeachment majority. (House Clerk)

Leadership’s post-election choices weigh more heavily than generic statements that impeachment remains available. Jeffries’s November 4 Speaker-candidacy letter emphasizes healthcare, food assistance, tariffs and ending the Iran war. It promises accountability but does not propose presidential impeachment. That omission alone would be weak evidence. His November 10 interview is more informative: he explicitly supports proceeding against Hegseth while leaving further impeachments undecided. I read the contrast as a sign that he distinguishes between an available power and an authorized campaign. (Agenda letter; official interview transcript)

Raskin’s caution reinforces that reading. At a November 5 event, he said Trump had committed impeachable offenses but favored restoring healthcare over beginning impeachment at that point. November 16 reporting described disagreement over whether to proceed and concern that impeachment could strengthen Trump politically. The latter account drew on interviews with 14 House Democrats: useful evidence of disagreement, but not a representative caucus poll. (GW Today; The Independent)

Public opinion supplies no clear counterweight to that restraint. The Economist/YouGov survey conducted November 4–6 found 41% supporting impeachment, 46% opposing and 13% unsure. Reuters/Ipsos, surveying November 6–9, asked a different question: 33% said pursuing impeachment would be good for the country, 42% bad, 23% were unsure and 2% skipped it. These are separate measures, not a trend series. Both caution against reading the election victory as an unambiguous impeachment mandate. (YouGov tables; Ipsos topline)

The strongest route toward impeachment is evidence that changes the political choice. Investigative preparation is concrete. Judiciary recruitment seeks counsel and investigative staff, while Natural Resources Democrats requested preservation of records from 36 agencies and private companies. These steps build capacity and protect evidence; neither establishes a presidential-impeachment operation. (Recruitment notice; preservation announcement)

A more direct investigative lead concerns reportedly more than $800 million in contributions to Trump-linked projects. Lawmakers requested information from fundraiser Meredith O’Rourke, with answers sought by November 25. The inquiry could reveal evidence of personal presidential involvement, but alleged exchanges of contributions for official benefits are not established wrongdoing. Separately, reported White House preclearance of agency testimony creates a potential confrontation. It can generate political pressure or simply slow fact-finding. (Fundraising inquiry; testimony restrictions)

What's non-obvious

The binding constraint is authorization, not the existence of an impeachment constituency. Democratic control, existing resolutions and angry rhetoric make impeachment look mechanically close. Yet the decisive gap lies between keeping an option alive and choosing a focused case, spending political capital on it and scheduling adoption. The evidence shows leaders making that distinction rather than merely waiting for majority control. (Jeffries interview)

Accountability efforts can also draw pressure away from Trump. On November 10, all 203 voting Democrats opposed referring the Hegseth resolution away from immediate consideration; the referral nevertheless passed 211–204. That demonstrates coordinated action around another target, not a presidential impeachment commitment. Senate conviction presents a similar distinction: it is irrelevant to this question’s legal threshold, but relevant to leaders deciding whether a House impeachment serves their goals. (Hegseth roll call; reported leadership concerns)

Uncertainties

The largest uncertainty is whether investigations produce compelling evidence, or a constitutional confrontation, early enough to change leadership’s decision within 2027. A new offense is not required; stronger corroboration of existing allegations could also change the calculation. The same investigative process can consume the year through contested records, testimony disputes and competing priorities.

There is no verified presidential-impeachment whip count, selected leadership-backed charge or adoption timetable in the evidence reviewed. That does not establish the absence of private planning. A public endorsement tied to specific articles, documented member commitments and scheduled proceedings would close much of the gap between general accountability promises and a credible adoption campaign.

Current intent is not a year-long commitment. Leadership could move toward impeachment after a crisis or remain focused on legislation and Cabinet accountability. The calendar is decisive: even a substantial inquiry that produces articles only after December 31, 2027, would not qualify. Those opposing possibilities support retaining 38.1% Yes and 61.9% No.

Forecast history

How Prolepsia’s forecast has movedOne forecast so far: 38% on 17 Nov 2026.
DateForecast
38% chance of yes

Sources Prolepsia read

  1. Democrats win US House and Senate, taking full control of Congress | AP Newsapnews.com
  2. How federal impeachment works | USAGovwww.usa.gov
  3. Party Divisions | US House of Representatives: History, Art & Archiveshistory.house.gov
  4. 2026 House Election Results by the Numbers | Cook Political Reportwww.cookpolitical.com
  5. Final Vote Results for Roll Call 175clerk.house.gov
  6. Dear Colleague Announcing Candidacy for Speaker of the House – Congressman Hakeem Jeffriesjeffries.house.gov
  7. GW Hosts Post-Election Discussion Examining Midterm Results and What Comes Next | GW Todaygwtoday.gwu.edu
  8. Democrats fear a rush job to impeach Trump could backfire and give him something to fuel his base | The Independentwww.the-independent.com
  9. # The Economist/YouGov Polld3nkl3psvxxpe9.cloudfront.net
  10. # TOPLINE & METHODOLOGYwww.ipsos.com

The question

This question asks whether the United States House of Representatives will formally impeach Donald Trump at any point between January 1, 2027, and December 31, 2027, inclusive. As of November 17, 2026, Donald Trump is serving his second term as President of the United States, having previously been impeached twice by the House of Representatives: on December 18, 2019, for abuse of power and obstruction of Congress, and on January 13, 2021, for incitement of insurrection. Both impeachments resulted in acquittals by the Senate. The November 3, 2026, midterm elections resulted in Democrats winning control of the House of Representatives, giving them a majority in the 120th Congress, which convenes in January 2027. Democrats have also won control of the Senate. These developments have increased discussion of potential congressional investigations and further impeachment proceedings against Trump. However, Democratic control of Congress does not necessarily mean that impeachment will occur. Under the U.S. Constitution, the House of Representatives has the sole power to impeach federal officials, requiring a simple majority vote to approve at least one article of impeachment. Impeachment is distinct from conviction and removal from office, which require separate proceedings in the Senate. This question concerns only whether the House formally impeaches Donald Trump during the specified calendar year, regardless of whether the Senate subsequently convicts or acquits him. Background sources include the U.S. House of Representatives' official impeachment history (https://history.house.gov/Institution/Impeachment/Impeachment-List/), USAGov's explanation of the impeachment process (https://www.usa.gov/impeachment), and Associated Press reporting on the November 2026 elections.

How it resolves

The question resolves YES if, at any point from January 1, 2027, through December 31, 2027, inclusive, the United States House of Representatives formally adopts at least one article of impeachment against Donald John Trump. This requires an affirmative vote by a simple majority of House members present and voting, provided a constitutional quorum is present, or another constitutionally valid procedure through which the House formally adopts an article of impeachment. The question resolves YES immediately upon the House's formal adoption of at least one article of impeachment, regardless of whether additional articles fail, whether the Senate conducts an impeachment trial, or whether Trump is subsequently convicted, acquitted, or removed from office. The question resolves NO if no article of impeachment against Donald Trump is formally adopted by the House during the specified period. In particular, the introduction of articles of impeachment, committee investigations, impeachment inquiries, committee approval of articles, public demands for impeachment, or procedural votes related to impeachment do not qualify unless the full House formally adopts at least one article. An impeachment resolution introduced in 2026 but approved by the full House in 2027 qualifies. Conversely, articles adopted before January 1, 2027, or after December 31, 2027, do not qualify. The primary resolution sources will be the official U.S. House of Representatives roll-call voting records, the Congressional Record, and Congress.gov, with the official House History, Art & Archives impeachment records serving as an additional authoritative reference. If these sources temporarily disagree, the official House Journal and Congressional Record documenting the final parliamentary disposition will take precedence over news reports or preliminary vote summaries. If the House has not adopted any qualifying article by the end of December 31, 2027, the question resolves NO. If official records are temporarily unavailable, resolution will be delayed until reliable documentation becomes available. The question will be annulled only if an extraordinary circumstance makes it permanently impossible to establish whether the House adopted an article of impeachment during the specified period.

Fine print

The relevant period is the 2027 calendar year, not the entirety of the 120th Congress. The start and end dates are interpreted using Washington, D.C., local time (Eastern Time). Donald Trump's previous impeachments in 2019 and 2021 do not count toward this question. A third impeachment would qualify regardless of the specific allegations, the number of articles adopted, or the political affiliation of the representatives supporting impeachment. A successful House impeachment vote qualifies even if Trump resigns, dies, or otherwise leaves office before a Senate trial occurs. If Trump leaves office before December 31, 2027, the question does not automatically resolve NO; a subsequent formal House impeachment during the specified period would still qualify, even if the constitutional validity of impeaching a former president were disputed. If Trump leaves office and no qualifying impeachment occurs by the deadline, the question resolves NO. A House vote to authorize an impeachment inquiry, establish an investigative committee, or refer impeachment articles to a committee does not qualify. Similarly, Senate proceedings concerning an impeachment adopted outside the specified period do not qualify. The outcome depends exclusively on formal action by the House of Representatives, not on whether impeachment is considered politically justified or likely to lead to removal from office.