Prolepsia forecastYes / no
Will the front December EU carbon futures contract close 2027 above €90 per tonne?
As of 15 November 2026, Prolepsia puts the chance of yes at 54%.
54%chance of yes
How Prolepsia reasons
The report Prolepsia wrote with this forecast.
How forecasts are made · Track record
TL;DR
The forecast is 54.3% Yes and 45.7% No, as of November 15, 2026. The balance favors a settlement above €90 only slightly: the relevant contract is already above the threshold, but the cushion is small compared with historical price swings.
Key evidence
- The target is December 2028 under the current schedule. December 2027 expires on December 20, 2027, before the year-end evaluation. Resolution uses the nearest unexpired December contract’s official daily settlement, not an intraday price or annual average (ICE expiry calendar).
- The directly relevant price is above €90. ICE’s November 13, 2026 last-trade observation for December 2028 was €95.12/t. That is a forecasting anchor, not an authenticated official settlement (ICE pricing).
- Historical volatility makes that lead fragile. ESMA’s daily-return variability figures for 2023, 2024 and 2025 imply roughly 24–35% annualized volatility. Its report also records a 29% price fall from January to March 2026 (ESMA).
- Supply tightening has real counterweights. The allowance cap declines, and 190,494,202 allowances are scheduled for reserve withdrawal over September 2026–August 2027. But the latest Commission report records 2025 ETS1 emissions down 2%, reducing compliance demand (reserve withdrawal; Commission report).
Uncertainties
Policy is the main structural uncertainty. October’s provisional reserve agreement preserves more allowances inside the reserve; it does not immediately auction them. November’s provisional industrial-allocation agreement adds flexibility, but its annual implementation remains unresolved (reserve agreement; industrial agreement).
Weather, gas prices, industrial activity and investor positioning can move the final settlement in either direction. An authenticated current settlement and complete contract-specific price history remain unverified. The forecast concerns one official settlement strictly above €90.00 and is conditional on the question not being annulled.
Read the full report
TL;DR
The forecast is 54.3% Yes and 45.7% No, as of November 15, 2026. This is a slight Yes lean, not a strong bullish call. The decisive point is that the relevant contract starts above €90, but its price cushion is small beside historical carbon-market volatility.
Context
The question concerns one official ICE Endex settlement at the end of 2027. It does not ask whether carbon trades above €90 during the year. Under the published schedule, December 2027 expires on December 20, 2027, while December 2028 expires on December 18, 2028. The nearest unexpired December contract at the evaluation date is therefore December 2028 (ICE contract calendar).
Exactly €90.00 resolves No. Only a settlement strictly above that threshold resolves Yes. The exposure is the existing EU ETS allowance market, not the separate ETS2 product. The forecast is conditional on non-annulment and follows the question’s provisions for exchange closures, suspensions and corrected settlements.
Evidence
The historical backbone is price variability, not a measured frequency of this exact event. No historical hit rate for comparable year-end threshold questions has been established. ESMA’s carbon-market report gives volatility figures of 1.9% in 2023, 2.2% in 2024 and 1.5% in 2025. These describe daily-return variability, measured through rolling 20-day windows. Their approximate annualized equivalents are 30.2%, 34.9% and 23.8%, respectively. Reading the original figures as annual volatility would badly understate risk (ESMA report).
The downside history is concrete. Prices fell 29% from January to March 2026, while funds reduced long positions. Average investment-fund net positions had moved from a net short of 14 thousand lots in 2024 to a net long of 48 thousand lots in 2025. That history shows how positioning can amplify a reversal. It does not establish current positioning in the December 2028 contract (ESMA report).
Against that background, the starting price gives only a modest advantage. ICE’s November 13, 2026 last-trade observations were €87.84/t for December 2026, €91.05/t for December 2027 and €95.12/t for December 2028. The last is the relevant anchor. These were last trades, not authenticated official settlements (ICE pricing). The December 2028 observation sits €5.12 above the threshold. That is a small buffer over a horizon extending through the end of 2027.
Supply contraction supports the Yes side. The Commission’s cap history shows a sustained decline, rather than a single tightening step:
| Year | Stationary and maritime cap, EUAs | Aviation cap, EUAs |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 1,386,051,745 | 27,563,529 |
| 2025 | 1,298,127,514 | 26,233,302 |
| 2026 | 1,185,420,090 | 24,903,076 |
| 2027 | 1,099,279,241 | 23,572,850 |
These are allowance quantities, not emissions forecasts (Commission Carbon Market Report). The legislated linear reduction factor is 4.3% of reference quantities through 2027 and 4.4% from 2028. It is not a compounded reduction from each preceding year’s cap (Commission cap guidance).
But a shrinking cap does not mean auction supply falls at the same speed. Allowances in circulation declined from 1,148,049,585 at the end of 2024 to 1,023,494,202 at the end of 2025. Scheduled reserve withdrawals consequently fall from 275,531,900 over September 2025–August 2026 to 190,494,202 over September 2026–August 2027. Under the current buffer rule, a lower circulating bank can mean less subsequent withholding (Commission circulation notice).
Published auction calendars illustrate the distinction. Scheduled auction volumes total 484,383,500 allowances for 2026 and 492,775,000 for 2027. The late-2027 portion remains indicative and subject to reserve adjustment. These calendars already incorporate announced withholding, so subtracting those withdrawals again would double-count tightening (EEX calendar comparison). Repayment of earlier REPowerEU frontloading also removes approximately 27.86 million allowances annually from Member-State auctions during 2027–2030; that adjustment likewise must not be counted twice (Commission auction update).
Policy flexibility adds another counterweight. The July review proposal would reduce reserve intake from 24% to 12% from 2028 and change historical aviation accounting by 173 million allowances. The accounting change is not new issuance, but it can reduce future withholding. These remain proposed changes, not established supply (Commission review proposal). They matter to a December 2028 contract even though the price is evaluated during 2027.
Two provisional agreements reinforce the direction toward flexibility without proving immediate oversupply. October’s compromise raises the reserve invalidation threshold from 400 million to 700 million allowances. It preserves up to 300 million more inside the reserve; it does not automatically put them into auctions (Council announcement). November’s industrial agreement provides approximately 121 million allowances over 2026–2030 through allocation measures. It is neither an immediate release of that quantity nor a corresponding increase in the overall cap (Council industrial-allocation announcement).
Demand evidence is mixed but does not support a strong scarcity call. The April release initially put 2025 overall emissions down 1.3%, industrial emissions down 2.5% and maritime emissions down approximately 3% (April Commission release). The later November report records total ETS1 emissions of 1,163 million tonnes CO₂e, down 2%; industrial emissions down 3.3%; maritime emissions down 4%; and aviation up 0.2%. The later reporting vintage is the better guide, though sector definitions prevent treating every difference as a clean revision (November Commission report).
Steel provides a bullish weak signal. ArcelorMittal reported all its European blast furnaces operating after restarts, alongside approximately 50% lower flat-steel imports year-on-year in the third quarter and expected double-digit fourth-quarter shipment growth. Management expected momentum to extend into 2027. Domestic production replacing imports can raise EU allowance demand without strong growth in final consumption. This is company evidence and guidance, not an EU-wide emissions forecast (ArcelorMittal presentation).
What's non-obvious
A tighter cap and more resilient auction supply can coexist. The reserve responds to the circulating allowance bank. As that bank shrinks, withholding can ease. Proposed accounting changes can strengthen that effect without creating new allowances. The simple story that every reduction in the bank produces an equal increase in scarcity misses this feedback.
The other trap is using the wrong contract. The late-2027 target is December 2028 under the current calendar, and its observed price already includes that delivery horizon (ICE calendar). Adding the upward futures-curve slope again as future appreciation would count the same maturity effect twice. My reading is that existing tightening and the above-threshold starting price justify the slight Yes lean, while flexible supply, falling emissions and large price swings prevent a stronger conclusion.
Uncertainties
The price anchor is not an authenticated current official settlement. A complete daily December 2028 settlement history and current options-implied volatility would improve the assessment of both the starting level and forward risk. Historical spot and rolling-index volatility are useful reference points, not exact measures of this contract’s future behavior.
The next circulation calculation, final late-2027 auction revisions, definitive 2028 auction supply and the annual distribution of industrial relief remain unresolved. Final legislation and implementation dates would clarify how much proposed flexibility reaches the relevant delivery period. Preserved reserve holdings should not be treated as auctions before a release mechanism actually applies.
Demand also remains open. Completed 2026 emissions, current contract-specific industrial hedge coverage and the breadth of steel restarts have not been established. Weather, gas prices and industrial activity can change compliance demand before the evaluation date. Since resolution rests on one official settlement rather than an annual average, a late market shock can decide the outcome even if the broader supply-tightening story remains intact.
Forecast history
| Date | Forecast |
|---|---|
| 54% chance of yes |
Sources Prolepsia read
- EUA Futureswww.ice.com
- ESMA50-481369926-34622 Market report: EU carbon markets 2026www.esma.europa.eu
- IMMC.COM%282026%29596%20final.ENG.xhtml.1_EN_ACT_part1_v6.docxpublications.europa.eu
- Commission cap guidanceclimate.ec.europa.eu
- COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION – Publication of the total number of allowances in circulation in 2025 for the purposes of the Market Stability Reserve under the EU Emissions Trading Systemeur-lex.europa.eu
- EEX calendar comparisonwww.eex.com
- ETS market stability reserve: Council and Parliament reach provisional agreement on targeted amendment - Consiliumwww.consilium.europa.eu
- Presentationcdn.arcelormittal.com
- ec.europa.euec.europa.eu
- Aktueller ICE EUA Carbon Emission Futures Kurs heute • onvistawww.onvista.de
The question
This question asks whether the front December European Union Allowance (EUA) futures contract traded on ICE Endex will finish 2027 with an official daily settlement price strictly above €90 per metric tonne of CO₂ equivalent. The forecast is made as of November 15, 2026, and will be evaluated using the final trading session of 2027, expected to be December 31, 2027, or the preceding trading day if the exchange is closed. EUA futures represent emission allowances under the European Union Emissions Trading System (EU ETS), with prices quoted in euros per metric tonne. The December contract is an important benchmark for European carbon markets. ICE Endex currently lists a December 2027 EUA futures contract scheduled to expire on December 20, 2027, meaning that the front December contract at the end of 2027 will ordinarily be the December 2028 contract. This specification interprets 'front December' as the nearest unexpired December-delivery EUA futures contract on the evaluation date, rather than specifically the December 2027 delivery contract. The forecast therefore concerns the December 2028 contract's official settlement price at the end of calendar year 2027, assuming the currently published expiration schedule remains unchanged. ICE Endex's published contract calendar confirms the December 2027 and December 2028 expiration dates. Source: https://www.ice.com/products/197/EUA-Futures/expiry
How it resolves
The question resolves YES if the official daily settlement price published by ICE Endex for the front December EUA futures contract on the final trading day of calendar year 2027 is strictly greater than €90.00 per metric tonne. It resolves NO if that settlement price is €90.00 or lower. The primary resolution source will be ICE Endex's official EUA Futures (product ID 197) daily settlement data, available through ICE's market data services or historical settlement records. The relevant contract will be the nearest December-delivery contract that has not expired on the evaluation date. Under the currently published contract schedule, this is expected to be the December 2028 contract, since the December 2027 contract expires on December 20, 2027. The evaluation date will be the last day in December 2027 on which ICE Endex publishes an official daily settlement price for the relevant contract, expected to be December 31, 2027, or the preceding trading day. Only the official exchange settlement price will count; intraday transaction prices, indicative quotes, bid-ask midpoints, and third-party calculated closing prices will not determine the result. If ICE's historical settlement data are not publicly accessible, an authenticated ICE settlement record obtained through a licensed market data provider may be used. If the relevant official settlement price cannot be established from ICE or a reliable historical record reproducing ICE's settlement data within 90 calendar days after the evaluation date, the question will be annulled. If ICE discontinues the standard EUA futures contract before the evaluation date without an officially designated economically equivalent successor, the question will also be annulled.
Fine print
The €90 threshold is exclusive: a settlement price of exactly €90.00 resolves NO, while €90.01 or higher resolves YES. Prices are evaluated in euros per metric tonne without currency conversion or inflation adjustment. The contract must represent allowances under the existing EU ETS for stationary installations and aviation, not the separate EU ETS 2 allowance futures product covering buildings, road transport, and additional sectors. The question concerns the price on a single specified trading day, not whether the contract trades above €90 at any point during 2027 or whether its annual average exceeds €90. The official exchange settlement price takes precedence over the last executed trade price. If ICE changes its contract listing or expiration schedule, the nearest unexpired December-delivery EUA futures contract on the evaluation date will be used. If ICE publishes a corrected official settlement price within the 90-day resolution window, the corrected figure will take precedence. If no standard EUA futures contract is available on the evaluation date because of an exchange suspension, the most recent official settlement within the preceding five trading days will be used; otherwise, the question will be annulled.
More public forecasts
Will front-month COMEX gold futures settle at or above US$4,400 per ounce on any trading day before 1 January 2027?
4%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
SCOTUS accepts sports event contract case by December 31, 2026?
<1%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will the CFTC finalize rules on event contracts covering elections and sports before 31 December 2027?
91%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will Dutch TTF natural gas futures average above €40 per megawatt hour in 2027?
85%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
What will the Brent crude front-month settlement price be on 31 December 2027, in US dollars per barrel?
77.6median
Prolepsia forecast
Will Brazil's 2026-27 soybean crop exceed 175 million tonnes, according to Conab?
71%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast