Prolepsia forecastYes / no
Will Dutch TTF natural gas futures average above €40 per megawatt hour in 2027?
As of 15 November 2026, Prolepsia puts the chance of yes at 85%.
85%chance of yes
How Prolepsia reasons
The report Prolepsia wrote with this forecast.
How forecasts are made · Track record
TL;DR
The forecast is 85.3% probability of Yes and 14.7% probability of No. Prices can fall sharply during 2027 and still produce an annual average above €40/MWh; a No outcome depends mainly on normalization arriving early and going deep.
Key evidence
- Normalization forecasts still exceed the threshold. ING projects a 2027 annual average of €48/MWh, with quarterly averages of €75, €45, €37 and €35/MWh. ABN AMRO projects €55/MWh annually. These are analyst forecasts, not guaranteed outcomes or exact reproductions of the resolving statistic. (ING; ABN AMRO)
- Gulf reopening does not mean full supply restoration. QatarEnergy's October 29 interview described approximately three-year repairs to damaged LNG capacity and an initial recovery ceiling near 83% of prewar output. Undamaged production can restart much faster, conditional on peace and available ships. (Reuters interview)
- Storage rebuilding extends the pressure beyond winter. EU storage stood at 70.76% on November 14. IEA simulations imply summer-2027 injections of 57–83 bcm, against a preceding five-year average of approximately 50 bcm. These are conditional requirements, not observed future demand. (GIE; IEA)
- New supply is a real counterweight. EIA projects US LNG exports of 15.1 Bcf/day in 2025, 17.6 in 2026 and 19.0 in 2027. Actual commissioning and export volumes matter more than announced capacity. (EIA)
Uncertainties
The decisive unknown is the timing of safe, sustained Gulf deliveries. Mild weather, stronger LNG output and continued demand restraint could accelerate the price decline. Conversely, delayed shipping recovery, cold weather or difficult storage replenishment would support Yes.
Today's elevated prices contribute nothing directly to the resolving average. The question uses equally weighted trading-day front-month settlements during 2027, not today's calendar-year futures quotation. The exact recent official settlement curve was not independently authenticated, and analyst forecasts do not precisely match every resolution convention. (ICE contract specifications)
Read the full report
TL;DR
The forecast is 85.3% probability of Yes and 14.7% probability of No for the 2027 average of daily front-month TTF settlements exceeding €40/MWh. The central distinction is between prices falling below €40 late in the year and the full-year average finishing at or below €40. Focus on the timing of sustained Gulf LNG deliveries and the early-year price path, not just the December price.
Context
As of November 15, 2026, Europe faces disrupted Gulf LNG supply and depleted storage ahead of winter. The reported near-€90/MWh December futures quotation signals current tightness, but it is not a verified official settlement for this analysis and contributes nothing directly to the 2027 resolving average. Vendor observations broadly corroborate the elevated price level. (November price observations)
The question measures the arithmetic average of official daily front-month settlements during 2027, with equal weight for each eligible trading day. It does not measure physical spot prices or the price of a fixed calendar-2027 contract today. ICE specifies quotation in euros/MWh and expiry two UK business days before delivery, so the rolling series can include early-2028 delivery contracts near the end of 2027. Equality with €40.00/MWh resolves No. (ICE contract specifications)
Evidence
History provides a warning against extrapolating crisis prices. The European Commission reports TTF day-ahead annual averages of €132/MWh in 2022, €41 in 2023 and €35 in 2024. These are physical-price observations, not the specified futures settlement series. They show that a large post-crisis decline is possible, but do not establish a reliable historical frequency for this exact event. The relevant lesson is that elevated prices are not a floor. (European Commission gas market report)
The current indicative forward curve also anticipates a substantial decline. The reported last-traded observations for the delivery months most relevant to the rolling series are below. These are not certified daily settlements, and the exact recent official curve remains incompletely authenticated. They serve as a directional cross-check, not a reconstruction of the eventual annual average. (ICE pricing page)
| Delivery month | Reported last-traded price, €/MWh |
|---|---|
| February 2027 | 88.670 |
| March 2027 | 85.295 |
| April 2027 | 73.370 |
| May 2027 | 68.160 |
| June 2027 | 66.145 |
| July 2027 | 65.535 |
| August 2027 | 64.610 |
| September 2027 | 63.600 |
| October 2027 | 62.030 |
| November 2027 | 61.240 |
| December 2027 | 61.235 |
| January 2028 | 61.060 |
The stronger evidence is that published normalization forecasts still put the annual average above the threshold. ING's November 3 outlook projects quarterly averages of €75, €45, €37 and €35/MWh during 2027, with a reported annual average of €48/MWh. Its path assumes early-2027 normalization of Gulf LNG flows. Thus, even its below-€40 late-year prices coexist with an above-€40 annual result. These forecasts are not certified equivalents of the question's exact contract-selection and trading-day conventions. (ING outlook)
ABN AMRO's November 11 outlook projects quarterly month-ahead averages of €80, €45, €45 and €50/MWh, and an annual average of €55/MWh. Those are average-price forecasts, distinct from its end-period forecasts. The agreement with ING supports the direction of the forecast, but two bank outlooks are not independent proof: both respond to many of the same supply and demand facts. (ABN AMRO outlook)
The annual-average arithmetic explains why timing matters. With approximately equal quarterly weights, a €75/MWh first quarter requires the remaining quarters to average €28.33/MWh or less for a No outcome. This is a conditional illustration, not an observed floor. No 2027 settlements have occurred, and a price collapse before the year begins would avoid that hurdle. Exact resolution uses actual settlement-day weights.
The physical supply problem has two parts: access to shipping and damaged production capacity. In the October 29 interview, QatarEnergy's chief executive described 12.8 million tonnes/year of damaged LNG capacity, approximately 17% of existing capacity, with repairs taking approximately three years. Undamaged production could restart within one week of peace if vessels were available, but output would initially remain near 83% of prewar levels. A fast partial restart and a long repair period can therefore both be true. (Reuters interview)
Shipping evidence is mixed. November 10 reporting estimated 13–15 Ras Laffan shipments per rolling ten-day window, compared with approximately 11 in October, but still around half the prewar pace. It estimated only 11 laden tankers leaving Hormuz in the ten days through November 8. Loading, passage and customer delivery are different measures, and incomplete vessel-position reporting limits confidence. Improving loadings are genuine evidence for recovery; they do not yet establish unrestricted delivery. (Shipping analysis)
Storage creates a second source of persistence. GIE's November 14 status showed EU storage at 801.24 TWh, or 70.76% of working capacity, with Germany at 57.45% and the Netherlands at 61.51%. Capacity fullness is not the share of winter consumption covered. The uneven distribution also matters for regional exposure. (GIE storage dashboard)
The IEA's winter simulations imply summer-2027 injection needs of 57–83 bcm to restore customary November inventories, compared with a preceding five-year average of approximately 50 bcm and a historical range of 38–69 bcm. Its January-restart case allows approximately eight weeks for production to ramp up. These are conditional simulations rather than forecasts of realized inventories, but they explain why winter tightness can carry into summer even after supply improves. (IEA security review)
New LNG supply is the main counterweight. EIA projects US exports of 15.1 Bcf/day in 2025, 17.6 in 2026 and 19.0 in 2027. That is meaningful relief, but a forecast of annual output is more useful than a sum of project nameplate capacities. Venture Global targets CP2 first LNG around mid-2027; its Plaquemines Phase 1 began commercial operation on October 31, while Phase 2 commercial operation remains targeted for mid-2027. These milestones imply staged contributions, not immediate full-year output. (EIA; Venture Global)
Demand adjustment also works against sustained high prices. The IEA reports non-Gulf LNG production rising 14%, or more than 40 bcm, during March–October 2026, offsetting approximately two-thirds of Gulf losses. It projects European gas demand down 3% and global demand down approximately 1.5% in 2026. These adjustments are substantive, though cheaper gas can bring some demand back. (IEA executive summary)
European sourcing faces an additional change during the forecast year. The adopted timetable prohibits long-term Russian LNG imports from January 1, 2027, and pipeline imports from September 30, potentially November 1 under the storage provision. This complicates replacement procurement, but is not a matching loss of global production: redirected Russian cargoes can displace other supplies elsewhere. (Council timetable)
What's non-obvious
A falling market can still resolve Yes. A forecast of sub-€40 prices late in 2027 does not answer the annual-average question. If early settlements remain high, later prices must fall substantially further to offset them. The important distinction is early normalization versus eventual normalization, not simply recovery versus continued disruption.
Reopening is also not a single event. Peace, insurable passage, available ships, functioning plants, loaded cargoes and delivered gas are separate steps. The same distinction applies to new supply: first LNG, commissioning output and commercial operation are not interchangeable. I read the evidence as supporting substantial recovery without assuming that recovery immediately restores low annual-average prices. Physical adequacy alone does not establish cheap gas; German storage scenarios find adequate supply in normal and warm weather while retaining shortage risk under extreme cold. (INES scenarios)
Uncertainties
The strongest route to No combines early, durable Gulf recovery with favorable weather, successful LNG ramp-ups and restrained demand. These forces can reinforce one another. Conversely, cold weather, stronger Asian cargo competition or delayed commissioning can keep Europe bidding for supply through the refill season. The forecast retains these uncertainties without treating today's prices as a mathematical commitment for 2027.
The largest evidence gaps concern sustained laden Hormuz exits, destination arrivals, producer-confirmed repair progress and actual new-project export volumes. The latest shipping developments and exact official settlement curve remain incompletely checked. Missing confirmation does not establish that recovery has stopped. Better shipment and operating data would narrow the uncertainty most.
Weather remains unresolved. NOAA's November discussion supports retaining a favorable-demand possibility, but an ENSO outlook is not a direct forecast of European winter gas demand. European temperature, wind generation, Asian demand and end-winter storage will provide more direct evidence. Finally, the available historical comparisons do not supply a calibrated base rate for this exact rolling-settlement event. (NOAA discussion)
Forecast history
| Date | Forecast |
|---|---|
| 85% chance of yes |
Sources Prolepsia read
- Gasprijs per m³ (grafiek) + Wat kost een kuub gas vandaag?www.energievergelijk.nl
- Dutch TTF Natural Gas Futureswww.ice.com
- Figure 31 – Comparison of TTF month-ahead, day-ahead and year-ahead prices (daily values)energy.ec.europa.eu
- ING outlookthink.ing.com
- Our energy price forecastsassets.ctfassets.net
- Exclusive-QatarEnergy buys US, other LNG to hedge future Hormuz disruptions By Reutersca.investing.com
- Qatar LNG Loadings Pick Up to Around Half of Pre-War Levelsgcaptain.com
- Gas Infrastructure Europe - AGSIagsi.gie.eu
- https://www.iea.org/files/42bb838f-d20d-4815-8554-32146033967d/GlobalGasSecurityReview2026.pdfwww.iea.org
- Short-Term Energy Outlook - U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)www.eia.gov
The question
This question asks whether the average settlement price of Dutch Title Transfer Facility (TTF) natural gas futures will exceed €40 per megawatt-hour (MWh) during the calendar year 2027, from January 1 through December 31, 2027. The Dutch TTF is Europe's principal benchmark for wholesale natural gas prices. The forecast will use the ICE Endex Dutch TTF Natural Gas Futures contract, which is denominated in euros per MWh. Specifically, the annual average will be calculated using the official daily settlement prices of the front-month (nearest actively traded delivery month) futures contract on each trading day in 2027, with each trading day receiving equal weight. As of November 15, 2026, European natural gas prices remain elevated amid geopolitical disruptions, LNG supply uncertainty, and relatively low European gas storage levels. ICE Endex data show that the December 2026 TTF futures contract traded near €90/MWh on November 13, 2026. Recent forecasts suggest substantial uncertainty about 2027 prices: ING's November 2026 global outlook projects an average Dutch TTF price of approximately €48/MWh in 2027, while other analysts anticipate some moderation as supply conditions improve. The €40/MWh threshold therefore represents a meaningful dividing line between sustained elevated European gas prices and a more substantial normalization of the market. Sources: ICE Endex (https://www.ice.com/products/27996665/TTF-Gas-Futures); ING Global Outlook, November 2026 (https://think.ing.com/uploads/pdf-replacements/Global_Macro_Outlook_2027.pdf).
How it resolves
The question resolves YES if the arithmetic mean of the official daily settlement prices for ICE Endex Dutch TTF Natural Gas Futures front-month contracts across all eligible trading days from January 1 through December 31, 2027, is strictly greater than €40.00/MWh. It resolves NO if the calculated average is €40.00/MWh or lower. The primary resolution source will be ICE Endex's official historical daily settlement prices for Dutch TTF Natural Gas Futures (product ID 27996665). For each eligible trading day, the front-month contract is defined as the contract with the earliest delivery month whose final trading day has not yet passed. The settlement price for that contract will be recorded in euros per MWh. The annual average will be calculated by summing those daily settlement prices and dividing by the number of eligible trading days for which official settlements were published. Weekends, exchange holidays, and days when no official settlement is published will be excluded. The calculation will use unrounded settlement prices to the precision available from ICE, with rounding performed only after comparison against the €40.00 threshold. ICE Endex's official historical settlement data will take precedence over third-party data vendors. If the necessary ICE settlement data are inaccessible, equivalent historical settlement prices from a reputable financial data provider such as Bloomberg, LSEG, or another provider reproducing ICE settlement prices may be used. If no sufficiently complete and reliable dataset can be obtained to establish the annual average, the question will be annulled rather than assigned an unsupported outcome. Resolution should occur after the final eligible trading day of 2027, once the necessary settlement data are available.
Fine print
The forecast concerns exchange-traded futures settlement prices, not physical spot-market prices, retail natural gas tariffs, LNG prices, or the price of a fixed calendar-year 2027 futures contract observed before or during 2027. The front-month contract changes as each monthly contract reaches its final trading day. No volume weighting, calendar-day weighting, seasonal adjustment, or inflation adjustment will be applied. All prices will remain denominated in nominal euros per MWh, so no currency conversion is required. A temporary price spike above €40/MWh will not automatically produce a YES outcome; the full-year arithmetic average must exceed that threshold. Similarly, individual days below €40/MWh do not automatically produce a NO outcome. If ICE changes the contract name, trading venue, or product identifier during 2027 without materially changing the underlying TTF benchmark, the direct successor contract will be used. If the benchmark is discontinued without a sufficiently comparable successor, the question will be annulled if the specified average cannot be determined reliably. The outcome is based on realized 2027 settlement prices, not forecasts published during 2026 or 2027.
More public forecasts
Will Germany's average day-ahead wholesale power price for 2027 be below €80 per megawatt hour?
7%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will the Henry Hub natural gas price average above USD 4 per MMBtu in 2027?
10%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
How much working natural gas will be in storage in the US Lower 48 for the week ending 4 December 2026, in billion cubic feet?
3,684median
Prolepsia forecast
Will front-month COMEX gold futures settle at or above US$4,400 per ounce on any trading day before 1 January 2027?
4%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will the front December EU carbon futures contract close 2027 above €90 per tonne?
54%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will COP31 in Antalya close more than 24 hours after its scheduled end?
82%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast