Prolepsia forecastYes / no

Will the World Bank Pink Sheet urea price for December 2027 be higher than its price for December 2026?

As of 17 November 2026, Prolepsia puts the chance of yes at 45%.

45%chance of yes

Yes 45%No 55%
Prolepsia forecast made

How Prolepsia reasons

The report Prolepsia wrote with this forecast.

How forecasts are made · Track record

TL;DR

The saved forecast is 45.3% Yes and 54.7% No. Supply recovery and easing costs favor a lower or unchanged December 2027 urea price, but the evidence supports only a modest No lean—not a strong falling-price call.

Key evidence

  • The latest price is far below the spring spike, despite a recent rebound. The World Bank reported urea at $390.00/mt in August, $407.50 in September and $420.00 in October 2026, versus $856.90 in April. Much of the exceptional increase has therefore already unwound before the December 2026 comparison month (November Pink Sheet).
  • The official outlook favors normalization, but forecasts annual averages. The World Bank projects $510/mt for 2026, $429 for 2027 and $368 for 2028. The 2027 projection is above October 2026’s observed price, illustrating why an annual-average decline does not establish a December-to-December decline (forecast table).
  • Supply conditions lean downward, conditionally. Recovering Middle Eastern exports, easing gas costs and new capacity underpin the World Bank’s outlook. Renewed conflict, shipping disruption and export restrictions are explicit upside risks (Commodity Markets Outlook).
  • Capacity announcements overstate assured incremental supply. Indorama’s Nigerian third line was commissioned in June 2026, placing much of its contribution in the starting baseline. Australia’s Perdaman project offers a later addition, but its expected H2 2027 manufacturing start leaves ramp-up risk (FMO; offtaker update).

Uncertainties

The largest unknown is the December 2026 starting price itself. October’s $420.00 is an observation, not the resolving baseline. Chinese export permissions, Gulf recovery, new-plant ramp-up and recovering fertilizer demand will determine whether additional supply actually lowers prices.

The comparison uses only the two December monthly averages in nominal USD/mt. Any increase counts as Yes; equality counts as No. Revisions available by March 31, 2028 apply, making small differences sensitive to corrections. The probabilities are conditional on the question remaining valid rather than being annulled.

Read the full report

TL;DR

The saved forecast is 45.3% Yes and 54.7% No. Treat this as a small directional edge toward December 2027 being equal to or below December 2026, not a strong falling-price call. Supply normalization supports No, while the unwinding of the spring price spike and the risk of renewed disruption limit that edge.

Context

The question compares two monthly average nominal prices in the World Bank’s Urea series: December 2027 against December 2026. Neither observation is available as of November 17, 2026. A strictly higher price resolves Yes; equality or a lower price resolves No. The comparison uses the underlying dataset values and revisions available by March 31, 2028. The forecast is conditional on the question not being annulled.

The latest published monthly observation is October 2026 at $420.00 per metric ton. Prices rose over August–October but remained far below the spring peak. The relevant benchmark is prilled spot urea, FOB Middle East—not a delivered import price, a retail fertilizer price or a price per tonne of nitrogen (November Pink Sheet).

Evidence

History provides little support for a strong unconditional directional call. Calculations from the World Bank’s monthly series show 32 December-to-December increases in 65 comparisons ending in 1961–2025, with three ties. More recent windows give different answers: 20 increases in 36 comparisons ending in 1990–2025, 15 in 26 ending in 2000–2025, seven in 16 ending in 2010–2025, and four in 11 ending in 2015–2025. These overlapping samples describe the same market history, not separate confirmations of a trend (historical monthly dataset).

The lesson is not that history predicts a decline. It is that the direction changes with the chosen period. Historical December-to-December log-return standard deviations were about 0.36–0.41 in the principal recent windows, showing that annual endpoint changes are large relative to a modest directional signal. The benchmark also changed from FOB Black Sea to FOB Middle East in March 2022, limiting the precision of older analogues (historical monthly dataset).

The current price path explains why the annual outlook needs careful reading. The supplied observations for 2026 show a sharp spring spike, a reversal and then a smaller rebound. All are monthly averages in USD/mt (November Pink Sheet).

Observed month in 2026 Urea price, USD/mt
March $725.60
April $856.90
May $770.50
June $453.10
August $390.00
September $407.50
October $420.00

The World Bank’s observed annual averages were $358.0/mt in 2023, $338.3 in 2024 and $422.7 in 2025 (November Pink Sheet). Its projections are $510 for 2026, $429 for 2027 and $368 for 2028. Those are annual-average forecasts, not December targets (October forecast table).

A falling annual average does not establish a falling December price. The January–October 2026 observations total $5,311. Matching the $510 full-year projection would require November and December to average $404.50. That calculation illustrates the averaging problem; it is not a December price forecast. The projected 2027 annual average of $429 also exceeds the latest monthly observation of $420. Much of the annual decline reflects the removal of unusually expensive spring months, rather than a required decline from the eventual December baseline.

The fundamentals still favor some further easing. The World Bank’s outlook rests on recovering Middle Eastern exports, easing gas costs and additional production capacity. Its further projected annual decline into 2028 supports a continuing normalization story rather than a single statistical effect (Commodity Markets Outlook). This supports the No lean, but does not make the endpoint comparison decisive.

China is central to that supply story. Industry commentary hosted by its Ministry of Commerce reported roughly 3 million tonnes/year of capacity commissioned in H1 2026 and another roughly 3 million expected in H2. It reported production growth of 8.9%, ahead of apparent-consumption growth of 6.5%. These are industry estimates, not a verified register of net new capacity or binding export permissions (MOFCOM-hosted commentary). Producer commentary put exports through September at roughly 3.8–3.9 million tonnes. Reopening was therefore already underway; further downward pressure requires additional shipments or more reliable export access (Fertiglobe transcript).

Project timing also matters. Indorama’s Nigerian third line was commissioned in June 2026, taking capacity across three operating lines to about 4.2 million tonnes/year. Much of that addition belongs in the December 2026 baseline, not exclusively in the following year (FMO project disclosure). Perdaman in Australia is a clearer later addition: its offtaker expected manufacturing in H2 2027. That supports additional availability, subject to commissioning and ramp-up (offtaker update). India’s Talcher plant was scheduled for commissioning in December 2027 after reaching 71.24% completion in February 2026. Commissioning during the comparison month is not the same as sustained commercial supply throughout it (parliamentary answer).

Gulf recovery is uneven. Fertiglobe reported UAE exports recovering from 56% of production in Q2 to 95% in Q3 2026, alongside 99% urea utilization at EFC and Sorfert over January–September (company results). Industries Qatar, by contrast, reported fertilizer-segment production falling from 705,000 tonnes in Q2 to 451,000 in Q3. Those are mixed-product figures, not urea-only output, but they show that normalization is incomplete (company results).

Gas and demand provide offsets. The IEA estimates global LNG supply falling 3%, or nearly 20 billion cubic metres, in 2026. Its adverse-weather and disruption scenario puts European storage below 10% by March 2027. That is a stress scenario, not a central prediction, but it describes a route to prolonged production constraints (IEA review). Fertilizer demand can also recover as affordability improves. The IFA outlook allows a rebound in nitrogen consumption in 2027/28, while its October assessment discounted a quick return to normal (IFA outlook; October assessment).

What's non-obvious

The key distinction is between more supply and more supply after the starting month. Capacity commissioned during 2026 and exports already restored by then affect both sides of this comparison. Counting them again as wholly new downward pressure in 2027 exaggerates the bearish case. The same error occurs when an annual-average decline is applied to a December baseline that already excludes most of the spring spike.

The benchmark also matters. Early-November commercial assessments quoted Omani granular urea around $425–430/mt FOB, against about $535 FOB Egypt. These are indicative assessments, not resolving observations, but the gap shows why high prices in one region should not be transferred directly to the World Bank’s Middle East prill series (Australian Fertilizer Corporation update). The useful question is whether additional tradable supply reaches the relevant market, not whether every regional fertilizer price falls together.

Uncertainties

The December 2026 baseline remains unknown. A low starting observation makes Yes easier to reach; a renewed late-2026 spike makes No easier. October’s price cannot stand in for that missing observation.

There is no verified binding Chinese export total for 2027, reliable monthly global urea balance for that year, or firm urea-only restoration schedule for Qatar and Iran in the supplied evidence. Export authorizations, plant-level output and shipping data would narrow those gaps. Their absence does not establish that supply will remain unavailable.

New-plant schedules also leave a gap between nameplate capacity and usable output. Actual commissioning, sustained operating rates and export deliveries would establish how much capacity affects December 2027. Renewed conflict, gas shortages or export restrictions work in the opposite direction; stronger crop demand can absorb part of any recovery.

Finally, revisions matter if the two observations are close. The underlying numerical values available by March 31, 2028 control resolution, not rounded summary prices. These uncertainties preserve substantial upside risk and explain why the saved forecast favors No only modestly.

Forecast history

How Prolepsia’s forecast has movedOne forecast so far: 45% on 17 Nov 2026.
DateForecast
45% chance of yes

Sources Prolepsia read

  1. November Pink Sheetthedocs.worldbank.org
  2. 商品价格网price.mofcom.gov.cn
  3. Transcriptfertiglobe.com
  4. Project detail - Indorama Eleme Fertilizer and Chemicals FZE - FMOwww.fmo.nl
  5. Incitec Pivot Fertilisers Stakeholder Update - 14 July 2026 | Incitec Pivot Fertiliserswww.incitecpivot.com.au
  6. Microsoft Word - RS UQ 2745sansad.in
  7. company resultswww.iq.com.qa
  8. Executive summary - Global Gas Security Review 2026 - IEAwww.iea.org
  9. Présentation PowerPointwww.fertilizer.org
  10. Fertilizer Crisis Response Bulletin #33 – Outlook from IFA - IFDCifdc.org

The question

This question asks whether the World Bank's Commodity Price Data (the Pink Sheet) will report a higher monthly average nominal price for urea fertilizer in December 2027 than in December 2026. The comparison will use the World Bank's published monthly urea price series, expressed in US dollars per metric ton (USD/mt), without adjusting for inflation. As of November 17, 2026, neither December 2026 nor December 2027 prices have been published. The November 2026 Pink Sheet, released November 3, 2026, reports a urea price of $420.00 per metric ton for October 2026, compared with $407.50 in September 2026 and $390.00 in August 2026. Urea prices have experienced substantial volatility during 2026, with the World Bank reporting considerably higher prices earlier in the year. The forecast concerns the direction of the price change between the two specified months, not the magnitude of that change or the annual average price in either year. The primary data source is the World Bank Commodity Price Data (Pink Sheet), available through the World Bank Commodity Markets website (https://www.worldbank.org/en/research/commodity-markets) and its historical monthly commodity price dataset (CMO-Historical-Data-Monthly.xlsx).

How it resolves

The question resolves YES if the monthly average nominal urea price reported by the World Bank Pink Sheet for December 2027 is strictly greater than the corresponding price for December 2026. It resolves NO if the December 2027 price is equal to or lower than the December 2026 price. Both prices must be taken from the same World Bank commodity price series, identified as 'Urea' in the historical monthly price dataset and reported in US dollars per metric ton. The primary resolution source will be the World Bank's CMO-Historical-Data-Monthly.xlsx workbook, specifically the 'Monthly Prices' worksheet, using the observations corresponding to 2026M12 and 2027M12. Resolution will occur using the data available as of March 31, 2028, allowing time for the December 2027 observation to be published and for initial data corrections. If the workbook is unavailable, the World Bank's official monthly Pink Sheet publications will serve as the fallback source, using the latest available officially published figures for the two months. If the World Bank revises either observation before the resolution cutoff, the revised values will be used. Revisions published after March 31, 2028, will not change the outcome. If one or both monthly observations remain unavailable from official World Bank sources by the cutoff, the question will be annulled rather than resolved YES or NO. The question will also be annulled if the World Bank discontinues the relevant urea series or changes its methodology in a way that makes the two monthly observations fundamentally incomparable without providing an official comparable historical series.

Fine print

The comparison uses nominal US-dollar prices per metric ton, without adjustments for inflation, exchange rates, or changes in purchasing power. Only the monthly average prices for December 2026 and December 2027 are relevant; prices in other months, annual averages, and annual percentage changes do not affect resolution. The comparison will use the underlying numerical values available in the World Bank's historical monthly dataset rather than rounded figures in summary publications, where greater precision is available. Any strictly positive difference between the December 2027 and December 2026 values counts as YES, regardless of its magnitude. If both observations are identical, the question resolves NO. If the World Bank renames or relocates the dataset while maintaining the same underlying urea price series, the successor publication may be used. Any changes to the geographic benchmark or pricing methodology will be assessed using the World Bank's official series documentation, with an officially maintained comparable series taking precedence over discontinuous observations. The forecast concerns the price measure published by the World Bank rather than the price paid by a particular purchaser, producer, or country.