Prolepsia forecastYes / no
Will the United States and Iran announce an agreement to reopen the Strait of Hormuz to commercial shipping by January 31, 2027?
As of 20 November 2026, Prolepsia puts the chance of yes at 22%.
22%chance of yes
How Prolepsia reasons
The report Prolepsia wrote with this forecast.
How forecasts are made · Track record
TL;DR
Probability of Yes: 21.7%. Probability of No: 78.3%. Continued mediation without a qualifying announcement is the most likely outcome by January 31, 2027: the two governments have a workable template for reopening the strait, but they have not publicly shown that they agree on who moves first.
Key evidence
The June Islamabad memorandum is the strongest precedent. It paired up to 60 days of no-charge commercial passage with U.S. blockade relief. It did not restore normal passage durably, but that is not the hurdle here. A temporary or conditional arrangement counts if both governments publicly accept a concrete reopening mechanism by the deadline.
The main obstacle is the order of concessions. Reuters reported in September that the sides were exploring a phased exchange of commercial passage for blockade relief. Iran later said it could restore passage within two days, but only after Washington met its conditions. November reporting still described Tehran as seeking relief first and Washington as seeking reciprocal steps and verifiable nuclear commitments from the outset. A faster reopening timetable does not resolve that disagreement.
Qatar’s November 17 briefing showed that the channel remained open, not that the governments had settled on a common text. Trump’s November 19 remarks about waiting until the new year concerned his next decision on the conflict, not a commitment to negotiate in January.
Uncertainties
Private talks could be further along than the public record shows. The clearest sign of a breakthrough would be a U.S. counteroffer that specifies what relief Washington will provide, paired with Iranian acceptance of the same conditions for commercial passage. Because the agreement can be conditional and does not have to take effect before the deadline, a late deal remains plausible. Another mediator meeting, a unilateral announcement, or a rise in shipping traffic would not establish that both sides had accepted a framework.
Read the full report
TL;DR
Probability of Yes: 21.7%. Probability of No: 78.3%. The decisive hurdle is getting both governments to publicly accept the same first exchange of concessions by January 31, 2027, not getting merchant ships back through the strait by then.
Context
As of November 20, 2026, the Strait of Hormuz remained severely disrupted. Before the war, about one-fifth of globally traded oil passed through it. The costs of disruption give both governments a reason to bargain, but the dispute is also about who controls passage and what conditions apply to commercial vessels (Congressional Research Service). Qatar and Oman remain involved in talks, and the parties have a concrete proposal to work from (Qatar Foreign Ministry; IRNA).
The question is whether both governments publicly accept a new or substantively renewed framework for meaningful commercial passage by January 31, 2027, at 23:59 UTC. A temporary or conditional corridor counts even if it never opens. A mediator’s announcement alone, a ceasefire that leaves shipping for later talks, or improved traffic without bilateral assent does not count. The record through February 7 can verify a timely announcement; it cannot extend the deadline.
Evidence
The strongest precedent is the June 17 Islamabad memorandum. It paired up to 60 days of no-charge commercial passage, on a best-efforts basis, with the start of U.S. blockade removal. The arrangement broke down and the blockade resumed on July 14 (Congressional Research Service). June establishes that the two governments can accept concrete shipping terms without resolving the wider conflict. Its breakdown also helps explain why assurances about what happens after the first concession now matter.
The April 7–8 truce is a weaker precedent. Both sides addressed passage, but their public conditions differed and there was no common published mechanism. The July 2022 Black Sea grain agreement shows that parties can agree to a commercial corridor while fighting continues. These cases establish feasibility, not a reliable base rate. April and June were episodes in the same war, and the Black Sea case involved a different set of concessions. The record is stronger on what form a deal could take than on how often such deals close within roughly 73 days.
The most promising route is a phased exchange of passage for blockade relief. Reuters reported on September 24 that representatives were exploring such a deal. Washington provided feedback on an earlier seven-day proposal. Tehran later said it could restore passage within two days of U.S. concessions. On November 16, Pakistan’s foreign minister said he was still waiting for a U.S. reply to the revised proposal (Associated Press). U.S. feedback on the earlier version and a pending response to the later one are consistent. Neither shows that the governments have accepted the same terms.
The dispute is over what each side gives up first. Reuters’ November reporting described Iran as seeking blockade relief, restored oil sales and access to frozen assets before substantive nuclear talks. Washington wanted reciprocal steps and verifiable nuclear commitments from the outset. These are reported bargaining positions, not agreed terms. But they explain why a quicker Iranian timetable has not produced a deal. Oman’s discussions about corridor security address how a reopening might work; they do not settle what Washington and Tehran must do to activate it (Al-Monitor).
The U.S. signals do not point to a quick decision. Qatar confirmed contacts with the U.S. leadership in November (Qatar Foreign Ministry). On November 12, Trump said the U.S. did not need a deal and redirected Vice President Vance to domestic work. On November 19, Trump reiterated his demand for full reopening (Associated Press) but said he was in no rush to decide his next move. That last remark concerned the conflict, not a diplomatic timetable. It is not evidence that talks must pause until January or that a negotiating session is planned for then.
Other channels have not shown a way around the sequencing dispute. China confirmed consultations by its regional envoy; the November 19 Shenzhen readout did not set out a Hormuz mechanism. At the IAEA, Washington and its allies pressed for access, while Iran’s envoy said inspection requests would still be assessed case by case. These public positions leave open the possibility of private movement, but they do not show a verifiable nuclear step that both governments are ready to trade for relief.
Shipping data show both the cost of the impasse and why Washington can afford some delay. IMF PortWatch recorded 67.37 vessel transits per day in November 2025, 3.84 per day in October 2026, and 44 reported transits over November 1–15, 2026, or 2.93 per day. The available series did not report later November days at the cutoff; missing rows are not zero transits. Separately, maritime authorities reported 308 crossings over November 5–11 under a broader measure and 106 U.S.-facilitated transits over November 15–18 (Joint Maritime Information Center). Those are different counts, not a single trend. They show that passage remains impaired but has not stopped. Partial access gives Washington an alternative to immediate concessions, even as disruption keeps an agreement valuable.
What's non-obvious
A two-day reopening plan is not evidence of a deal two days away. Iran shortened the time it says it needs to restore passage after U.S. action. It did not publicly give up the demand for that action to come first. A draft corridor and recurring mediator meetings can make a deal faster to conclude once the political terms line up. They do not show that the terms have lined up.
The reverse distinction matters just as much: the strait does not have to reopen in practice for the forecast to resolve Yes. Both governments could accept a renewed June-style bargain with implementation details left for later. On the other hand, more tankers could get through under existing arrangements and the outcome would still be No. The signal to watch is matching public commitments about commercial passage and the conditions that trigger it, not the vessel count.
Uncertainties
The main unknown is whether Washington and Tehran have privately converged on a reciprocal first step. There is no verified U.S. counteroffer to the revised Iranian plan in the public record at the cutoff. That does not rule out private bargaining. An authorized U.S. proposal spelling out specific relief, followed by Iranian language accepting the same timing and commercial-passage terms, would be more informative than another round of intermediary meetings.
A late agreement is the strongest risk to the forecast. The June text gives negotiators a starting point, and neither government has to restore shipping before announcing a deal. The remaining time is enough to endorse an interim package if the principals settle who does what first. But a draft neither side fully accepts, a regional arrangement without U.S. assent, or a unilateral claim that the other side has agreed would still fall short. Public confirmation from both governments is the test.
Forecast history
| Date | Forecast |
|---|---|
| 22% chance of yes |
Sources Prolepsia read
- The Strait of Hormuz: Security Developments and Impacts on Oil, Gas, and Other Commodities - EveryCRSReport.comwww.everycrsreport.com
- Qatar Foreign Ministrymofa.gov.qa
- Araghchi meets Qatari delegation in Muscatirna.com
- Islamabad Memorandum of Understanding Between the United States of America and the Islamic Republic of Iran | The American Presidency Projectwww.presidency.ucsb.edu
- Trump agrees to two-week ceasefire, Iran says safe passage through Hormuz possible By Reuterswww.investing.com
- ECO Backs Iran’s Two-Day Proposal: Araqchi - Politics news - Tasnim News Agencywww.tasnimnews.ir
- Associated Pressapnews.com
- Trump and Tehran gamble on time as Iran war stalemate deepens | MarketScreener Canadaca.marketscreener.com
- US, Iran exchange fire despite talks with mediators - AL-MONITOR: The Middle Eastʼs leading independent news source since 2012www.al-monitor.com
- Trump to Axios: I'm "not rushing into a decision" on Iranwww.axios.com
The question
This question asks whether the United States and Iran will publicly announce a new bilateral agreement, or an agreement accepted by both governments through intermediaries, to reopen the Strait of Hormuz to commercial shipping between November 20, 2026, and January 31, 2027, inclusive. The agreement may be temporary, phased, conditional, or permanent, provided it explicitly establishes a mutually accepted framework for restoring commercial vessel passage through the strait. The Strait of Hormuz is a strategically important maritime passage connecting the Persian Gulf with the Gulf of Oman and international shipping routes. Before the outbreak of the US-Iran war in February 2026, approximately one-fifth of globally traded oil passed through the strait. Iranian attacks and restrictions on commercial shipping have severely disrupted maritime traffic and global energy markets. Previous US-Iran ceasefire arrangements in April and June 2026 included provisions concerning commercial shipping, but these arrangements did not produce a durable restoration of normal passage. According to Congressional Research Service reporting, disputes over control of the strait and the conditions governing commercial transit remain central obstacles to a lasting settlement. Sources: Congressional Research Service, August 2026 (https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R45281.html); Congressional Research Service, November 2026 (https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/2026-11-04_RS21534_e6ff16a9cb34dc59fd4b0b01e95e8e91d02d79db.pdf). As of November 20, 2026, negotiations remain unresolved. Reuters reported in September that US and Iranian representatives were exploring a phased agreement linking the reopening of the strait to the lifting of the American economic blockade of Iran. On November 14, the Associated Press reported that Qatar continued mediating discussions on an interim arrangement to restore commercial shipping, although significant political obstacles remained. On November 19, President Donald Trump reiterated that Iran needed to fully reopen the strait. These developments indicate that reopening the waterway remains an important unresolved diplomatic issue. Sources: Reuters, September 24, 2026 (https://www.investing.com/news/commodities-news/us-and-iran-discuss-phased-deal-to-reopen-hormuz-and-end-us-blockade-sources-say-4915884); Associated Press, November 14, 2026 (https://apnews.com/article/02378df1ec3073d2c0f8f162e697d181); Associated Press, November 19, 2026 (https://apnews.com/article/25e17ec8d9c55fbff960d5631eaba71d). The forecast concerns the public announcement of a qualifying agreement, rather than the actual restoration of normal commercial shipping volumes. The relevant deadline is January 31, 2027, at 23:59 UTC.
How it resolves
The question resolves YES if, between November 20, 2026, and January 31, 2027, inclusive, the governments of the United States and Iran publicly confirm that they have reached a new agreement providing for the reopening or restoration of commercial shipping through the Strait of Hormuz. A qualifying agreement must satisfy all of the following conditions: (1) Both the United States and Iran must affirmatively accept the agreement, either through official government statements, an authenticated joint declaration, or public confirmation by authorized representatives. (2) The agreement must explicitly address the restoration of commercial shipping through the Strait of Hormuz, including provisions for allowing or facilitating commercial vessel passage. (3) The agreement must reflect a concrete diplomatic understanding between the parties rather than merely an offer, negotiating proposal, statement of intent to negotiate, or unilateral declaration. (4) The agreement must be publicly announced or confirmed by the deadline. Agreements announced by a third-party mediator, including Qatar, Oman, or another government, qualify if both the United States and Iran publicly confirm their acceptance by the deadline. The confirmation does not have to occur in a simultaneous announcement or a single joint statement. An agreement may qualify even if implementation is scheduled for after January 31, 2027, or depends on specified conditions, such as sanctions relief, a ceasefire, reciprocal security commitments, or the establishment of designated shipping corridors. However, the agreement must contain an explicit commitment or mutually accepted mechanism for reopening the strait to commercial shipping. A general ceasefire or diplomatic framework that merely identifies reopening as a subject for future negotiations does not qualify. The question resolves NO if no qualifying agreement has been publicly announced and accepted by both governments by January 31, 2027, at 23:59 UTC. It also resolves NO if negotiations produce only a unilateral announcement, an unaccepted proposal, a general ceasefire without concrete commercial-shipping provisions, or an agreement exclusively between Iran and third countries without US acceptance. Primary resolution sources will be official statements and publications from the US White House, US Department of State, and relevant Iranian government authorities, including the Iranian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Official statements from recognized mediating governments may provide supporting evidence, but an intermediary's announcement alone is insufficient without confirmation of acceptance by both parties. Secondary sources will include Reuters, the Associated Press, and other established international news organizations reporting on official announcements. If government statements are unavailable or ambiguous, contemporaneous reporting that directly quotes or reliably documents affirmative confirmation from authorized representatives of both governments may establish that the criteria were met. Anonymous reports of a deal, without public confirmation from both governments, will not suffice. The outcome will be determined from the public record available through February 7, 2027, allowing time to verify announcements made before the deadline. Reports published after January 31 may establish that a qualifying announcement occurred before the deadline, but an agreement first announced after the deadline will not qualify. If a qualifying agreement is announced before the deadline but subsequently collapses, is violated, or is not implemented, the question still resolves YES because the forecast concerns the announcement of an agreement rather than its successful implementation.
Fine print
For purposes of this question, commercial shipping includes civilian merchant vessels transporting oil, liquefied natural gas, other commodities, or general commercial cargo. The agreement need not immediately restore prewar shipping volumes or unrestricted navigation. A phased reopening, temporary safe-passage arrangement, or mutually agreed commercial corridor qualifies if it represents an agreed mechanism for restoring meaningful commercial transit through the Strait of Hormuz. An agreement that permits only isolated humanitarian shipments, individual vessel evacuations, or exceptional one-time passages does not qualify unless it also provides a broader framework for restoring ordinary commercial shipping. A bilateral US-Iran agreement can qualify even if additional countries, including Oman or Gulf states, participate in its implementation. Conversely, an agreement concluded solely between Iran and Oman, or between Iran and other regional governments, does not qualify unless the United States explicitly accepts the relevant arrangement as part of a diplomatic agreement with Iran. The agreement does not need to be legally binding or formally signed. An officially announced political agreement or memorandum of understanding is sufficient if both governments acknowledge accepting its substantive shipping provisions. An announcement that merely reiterates an earlier agreement without establishing new or renewed commitments does not qualify. However, a newly negotiated extension, reinstatement, or substantive modification of an earlier agreement qualifies if it explicitly provides for reopening commercial shipping and both governments affirmatively accept it during the forecast period. If one government announces an agreement and the other government explicitly rejects its existence or disputes having accepted its terms, the announcement does not qualify unless both parties subsequently confirm a mutually accepted arrangement before the deadline. The formal completion of any additional arrangements governing tolls, maritime security, shipping inspections, or traffic administration is not required unless the announced agreement itself makes the existence of an agreed reopening framework contingent on those arrangements being negotiated later. An agreement that already establishes a reopening commitment but schedules implementation details for later can qualify. Actual shipping traffic, insurance rates, maritime security advisories, and vessel-tracking data may provide useful context but are not independent resolution criteria. A de facto reopening without a qualifying bilateral announcement resolves NO.
More public forecasts
Will the United States and Iran sign or jointly announce an agreement on Iran's nuclear programme between 1 January and 31 December 2027?
34%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Strait of Hormuz traffic returns to normal by December 31?
3%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will the average daily number of tanker transits through the Strait of Hormuz in December 2027 be at least 80% of the 2025 daily average, according to IMF PortWatch?
29%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will the United States end its naval blockade of Iranian ports by January 31, 2027?
19%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will S&P, Moody's or Fitch downgrade the United States' long-term sovereign credit rating between 1 January and 31 December 2027?
19%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast
Will the United States carry out air or missile strikes on Iranian territory between 1 January and 31 December 2027?
88%chance of yes
Prolepsia forecast